NEWS
GOVERNMENT
SECURITY
RESOURCES
PODCAST
STATE OF IT
DIGITAL NATION

BUSINESS CLOUD DATA CENTRE

EDUCATION FINANCE HARDWARE

HEALTHCARE INDUSTRIAL NETWORKING

PROJECTS SOFTWARE STORAGE

STRATEGY TECHNOLOGY TELCO/ISP

BENCHMARK AWARDS Insights MEDIA HUB

PARTNER CONTENT PARTNER HUBS PROMOTED CONTENT

REPORTS

NEWS

BUSINESS CLOUD DATA CENTRE EDUCATION FINANCE HARDWARE HEALTHCARE INDUSTRIAL NETWORKING PROJECTS SOFTWARE STORAGE STRATEGY TECHNOLOGY TELCO/ISP

GOVERNMENT SECURITY RESOURCES

BENCHMARK AWARDS Insights MEDIA HUB PARTNER CONTENT PARTNER HUBS PROMOTED CONTENT REPORTS

PODCAST STATE OF IT DIGITAL NATION

Log In

Email:

Password:

Remember me | Forgot password?

Don't have an account? Register now!

Photos: The 10 moods of Stephen Conroy

Fresh into opposition and relishing every minute. The best of three hours of Senate hearings on the NBN, condensed into 10 frames.

on Nov 29 2013 6:55AM

0 Comments

CHESHIRE CAT CONROY. The former communications minister obviously holds the former DBCDE assistant secretary for NBN and fibre rollout regulation, Philip Mason, in high regard. It was one of at least two occasions where Senator Conroy hoped to coax Mason to join his departmental colleagues in giving evidence.

THIRSTY CONROY. More work (and admiration) for the former DBCDE's Philip Mason. "Mr Mason, you want to come forward and help?" Conroy questioned. The answer, again, was no.

SALESMAN CONROY. Fresh from a batch of questions about whether Telstra's copper network was really a good buy or not, Senator Conroy attempted to close a sale of his own. "I've got a harbour bridge that I'd like to sell you next. Any interest?" he asked. Unfortunately the property had to be withdrawn from sale after attracting no bids. [The Senator has quite a fondness for a lanes-on-the-harbour-bridge analogy when differentiating between FTTP and FTTN].

CONROY, TIME TRAVELLER. One of several attempts to have questions answered now, rather than after the conclusion of the NBN review initiated by now Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull.

EVIL EYE CONROY. Enough said.

FLIPPANT CONROY. The Department of Finance representative, Robin Renwick, was given a relatively easy passage, owing to the small amount of time he'd been in the role. But he wasn't let off the hook entirely. After telling Senator Conroy that NBN Co hadn't "raised any issues" around their financial projections in weekly meetings with the new government and agencies, Senator Conroy raised the prospect that Renwick be more proactive. "Well, I thought the job of the meeting was for you to raise questions, not for you to just sit there. What, they just come in, give you a piece of paper you say thanks, see you later?"

INCREDULOUS CONROY. The questions turned to whether gigabit speeds will be possible on a fibre-to-the-node network. That the thought was even entertained by those opposite him sparked a rush of incredulity. "Could they [NBN Co] offer a product that it's not possible to deliver on fibre to the node? Could they offer a product that it's just not technically feasible to offer?"

JOVIAL CONROY. A long pause followed as the panel researched start-up dates for 250Mbps, 500Mbps and 1Gbps fibre products on the NBN. Senator Conroy couldn't resist a joke about the glacial pace. "We're still having difficulty" finding the information, NBN implementation special adviser Mark Heazlett said. "Are you on wireless?" Conroy joked.

NO NONSENSE CONROY. Exploring any anomalies in publicly-presented figures on cost per premise of rolling out fibre eventually resulted in a postulation that the question had been answered. Senator Conroy didn't think so. "No, you've talked a lot. Would you like me to ask it to you again and perhaps we can stay precise on the question rather than answering questions I haven't asked?"

PROFESSOR CONROY. Senator Conroy's love of physics is well known to most NBN watchers. A logical test for those laws is the range of services that can be supported on an FTTP network versus one that is based on FTTN. Just how many NBN fibre products could run on FTTN is "yet to be determined", if one believes the Department of Communications. Senator Conroy doesn't: " It's a laws of physics question. It's not a yet to be determined question. The laws of physics have been determined a few hundred years ago, so I'd like a truthful answer… and yet to be determined is not a truthful answer."

Tags:

Aussie Broadband watches its NBN excess bandwidth bill climb

TIO Judi Jones resigns

Telstra broaches ADSL's 'end of life'

Partner Content

Partner Content Deadline to enter 2021 IoT Awards extended

Promoted Content From 30 people to 6 million: How workplace tech is driving Movember's global community

Promoted Content COVID has sped up 'data gravity': how can IT leaders respond?

Promoted Content Why simplicity is the winning formula for CX success

Partner Content Solving the post-COVID digital access control headache

Promoted Content 4 essentials for protecting data in the new normal

Digital Nation

"Kill all you see." The tragic, real world consequences of Facebook’s algorithms

COVER STORY: Data centre sustainability scrutiny puts emissions in the spotlight

Next generation of Digital Giants growing faster than the originals: Ray Wang

Q: The trick to effective personalisation? A: Don’t do personalisation

Expect dramatic value chain disruptions every four years: McKinsey Global Institute

Latest Comments

Events

SAP e'ffect 2021

Most popular tech stories

"Kill all you see." The tragic, real world consequences of Facebook’s algorithms

Expect dramatic value chain disruptions every four years: McKinsey Global Institute

COVER STORY: Data centre sustainability scrutiny puts emissions in the spotlight

Didier Bonnet, Ray Wang, Kristine Dery, Gerd Schenkel and Bill Ruh tackle digital transformation

Cashless Australia?: Woolworths transactions hit 90 per cent digital, bank withdrawals tank, Paypal surges
PwC Australia acquires Sydney MSSP WebSecure Technologies

MOQ Group names new CEO

Melbourne's Acurus helps update Bakers Delight to SD-WAN

HTC’s Focus 3 more than VR hype, say two Aussie resellers

Transpire taps Telstra Purple talent to lead foray into cloud
5 top-tips every entrepreneur should know before starting a business

Three critical lessons about building your own Bootstrapped company

Get 2-3x more candidates using these proven techniques

How to build a future-ready workforce

How to lock down your web security
Giving water utilities IoT technology "freedom"

Building an IoT 'solution of the commons'

2021 IoT Awards winners to be announced on November 9

Leash IT begins marketing Social Distancing Bracelet

Digital tech is the future, but a new report shows Australia risks being left in the past

OTHER TECH SITES: BIT | CRN Australia | IoT Hub

All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Log In

Don't have an account? Register now!

Email:

Password:

Remember me | Forgot your password?

Gov pressed to end reliance on IT contractors, fill APS "capability gap"

Telstra, Optus trade multi-gigabit speed tests on 5G

ICAC pings two former TAFE NSW execs over software deal

Cyber incident takeover powers reintroduced to parliament

Australia to make permanent company laws allowing virtual AGMs

Photos: The 10 moods of Stephen Conroy

Fresh into opposition and relishing every minute. The best of three hours of Senate hearings on the NBN, condensed into 10 frames.

Most popular tech stories

"Kill all you see." The tragic, real world consequences of Facebook’s algorithms

Expect dramatic value chain disruptions every four years: McKinsey Global Institute

COVER STORY: Data centre sustainability scrutiny puts emissions in the spotlight

Didier Bonnet, Ray Wang, Kristine Dery, Gerd Schenkel and Bill Ruh tackle digital transformation

Cashless Australia?: Woolworths transactions hit 90 per cent digital, bank withdrawals tank, Paypal surges

PwC Australia acquires Sydney MSSP WebSecure Technologies

MOQ Group names new CEO

Melbourne's Acurus helps update Bakers Delight to SD-WAN

HTC’s Focus 3 more than VR hype, say two Aussie resellers

Transpire taps Telstra Purple talent to lead foray into cloud

5 top-tips every entrepreneur should know before starting a business

Three critical lessons about building your own Bootstrapped company

Get 2-3x more candidates using these proven techniques

How to build a future-ready workforce

How to lock down your web security

Giving water utilities IoT technology "freedom"

Building an IoT 'solution of the commons'

2021 IoT Awards winners to be announced on November 9

Leash IT begins marketing Social Distancing Bracelet

Digital tech is the future, but a new report shows Australia risks being left in the past

Gov pressed to end reliance on IT contractors, fill APS "capability gap"

Telstra, Optus trade multi-gigabit speed tests on 5G

ICAC pings two former TAFE NSW execs over software deal

Cyber incident takeover powers reintroduced to parliament

Australia to make permanent company laws allowing virtual AGMs

Photos: The 10 moods of Stephen Conroy

Fresh into opposition and relishing every minute. The best of three hours of Senate hearings on the NBN, condensed into 10 frames.

Related Articles

Aussie Broadband watches its NBN excess bandwidth bill climb

TIO Judi Jones resigns

Telstra broaches ADSL's 'end of life'

Most popular tech stories

"Kill all you see." The tragic, real world consequences of Facebook’s algorithms

Expect dramatic value chain disruptions every four years: McKinsey Global Institute

COVER STORY: Data centre sustainability scrutiny puts emissions in the spotlight

Didier Bonnet, Ray Wang, Kristine Dery, Gerd Schenkel and Bill Ruh tackle digital transformation

Cashless Australia?: Woolworths transactions hit 90 per cent digital, bank withdrawals tank, Paypal surges

PwC Australia acquires Sydney MSSP WebSecure Technologies

MOQ Group names new CEO

Melbourne's Acurus helps update Bakers Delight to SD-WAN

HTC’s Focus 3 more than VR hype, say two Aussie resellers

Transpire taps Telstra Purple talent to lead foray into cloud

5 top-tips every entrepreneur should know before starting a business

Three critical lessons about building your own Bootstrapped company

Get 2-3x more candidates using these proven techniques

How to build a future-ready workforce

How to lock down your web security

Giving water utilities IoT technology "freedom"

Building an IoT 'solution of the commons'

2021 IoT Awards winners to be announced on November 9

Leash IT begins marketing Social Distancing Bracelet

Digital tech is the future, but a new report shows Australia risks being left in the past

Log In