The attacker would have to know the target name of the window being replaced, and would require the attacker's website and the target website to be open at the same time.
Secunia rated the vulnerability as 'moderately critical', its third most severe security rating on a five-step scale.
A Microsoft spokesman denied that the reported flaw describes a vulnerability in its software.
The said in an emailed statement that Secunia describes the issue as "a by-design behaviour in popular web browsers that allows a website to open or reuse a pop-up window".
Users will be able to tell that they have been directed to a phishing website because the pop-up window displays an address bar.
Secunia issued a warning about a similar vulnerability in Internet Explorer 5 and 6 in 2004.
Today's alert is the fourth alleged security vulnerability that Secunia has unearthed in Internet Explorer 7 since the browser was launched earlier this month.
In addition to today's denial, Microsoft has dismissed one other Secunia report because it affected Outlook Express rather than IE7. Microsoft has confirmed the two other vulnerabilities.