As reported on iTnews, the Department of Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy issued a tender last week asking for assistance in putting a dollar value on its spectrum assets - which would suggest the Department is leaning toward the idea of an auction.

A spokesperson for Senator Conroy said the discussion paper released this afternoon, aims to gauge public perception around the possibility of mobile spectrum auctions, while the discussion paper released earlier this month by ACMA (The Australian Media and Communications Authority) is concerned with technical issues.
Senator Conroy said that while mobile spectrum licences do not begin expiring until 2013 [see table below], spectrum licencing is a "complex issue that will take some time to address."
The discussion paper seeks to explore whether Australians feel it is "in the public interest" for ACMA to allow mobile carriers to simply renew their licenses. Without such a declaration by the Minister of 'public interest', ACMA puts the spectrum back on the market for the highest bidder.
The paper also asks the public for their definition of what "the public interest" is - a term that is very loosely defined in Australian law.
Both renewal and reassignment (auctions) of mobile spectrum licenses have their advantages, the paper states.
"Renewal provides certainty to incumbents and therefore encourages investment and innovation," the paper reads. "Renewal could also minimise or negate the effects of service disruption to millions of consumers who currently use services offered on spectrum licensed bands"
Reassigning the license via an auction, by contrast, allows "the license to achieve its highest value use" and supports competition by "providing an opportunity for new entrants to enter the market."
Noticeably absent from the paper is any mention of how spectrum auctions are means by which successive governments have topped up their cash supply - a tempting option in the current climate.
The paper also called for comment as to whether there is sufficient competition in terms of mobile services, whether 15-year terms are appropriate for spectrum licenses, and whether the community receives an "appropriate rate of return" on the licensing of finite mobile spectrum.
The paper says future spectrum licensing also needs to account for future 4G technologies such as Long Term Evolution (LTE) "and also the continued development of broad spectrum applications such as Ultra-Wideband (UWB) and cognitive radio."
LTE, for example, is likely to require twice as much bandwidth than 2G phone services.
15-Year Radiofrequency Spectrum Licences
Licence Expiry Date |
Licensed Band |
Band Usage
|
31 May 2012 |
500 MHz |
Land Mobile - Taxies, Couriers ETC |
17 June 2013 |
800 and 1800 MHz |
Personal Communications Systems (PCS) - 2G mobile services |
31 January 2014 |
28 & 31 GHz |
Broadband Wireless Access (BWA) - AAPT licensed |
3 May 2015 |
1800 MHz |
Personal Communications Systems (PCS) - 2G mobile services |
24 July 2015 |
2300 MHz |
Multipoint Distribution (MDS) - Pay TV and wireless broadband |
13 December 2015 |
3.4 GHz |
Fixed Wireless Access - Pay TV and wireless broadband |
17 June 2016 |
27 GHz |
Broadband Wireless Access - Satellite up and down links |
11 October 2017 |
2.1 GHz |
3G Mobile Services |
26 April 2021 |
20 GHz |
Defence satellite links |
26 April 2021 |
30 GHz |
Defence satellite links |
Source: ACMA website as at 20 December 2007 (http://web.acma.gov.au/pls/radcom/spectrum_search.cat_listing)