Day 22: IIA attempt to intervene in iiNet copyright case dismissed

 

Nothing new to add.

The Internet Industry Association’s application to intervene in the copyright case between ISP iiNet and the film industry as a ‘friend of the court’ has been dismissed.

The decision was handed down by Justice Cowdroy on the final day of sitting in the Federal Court in Sydney.

The court was adjourned immediately following the decision to allow both sides time to digest the reasons for the dismissal.

The association’s chief had earlier in the week been subjected to a brief - but intense - cross-examination by the film industry, who accused the IIA of having “nothing new” to add to the case.

The film industry’s barrister Tony Bannon had urged Justice Cowdroy at the time to dismiss the application on that basis.

In a statement issued this afternoon, IIA chief executive, Peter Coroneos said the association was "naturally disappointed" but "heartened" by comments made by Justice Cowdroy in his decision.

The IIA quoted Cowdroy's decisions as saying: "If the IIA intended by its application for intervention to bring to the Court's attention the importance of its decision in these proceedings, it can take such fact as noted," Cowdroy noted in his decision.

"The Court is, and always has been, well aware of the ramifications of the outcome of its decision for ISPs, rights holders, and the development of the internet more broadly."

Coroneos said: “This is a very good outcome as the judge has acknowledged that he will consider the impacts on the broader industry which is what the IIA was keen to establish."

Earlier, the final day of proceedings resumed 45 minutes later than scheduled to enable the applicant's time to prepare their final written submissions.

The case continues. You can follow the case in-full here. For a background on the case, click here.


Day 22: IIA attempt to intervene in iiNet copyright case dismissed
"@apaulefont, why should the operator of a toll road establish a relationship with copyright holders who purport to have information that some trucks using the tollway may be carrying loads of EPRs ..."
By anonymous
 
 
 
Comments: 13
Digger11
Nov 26, 2009 12:37 PM
Good - IIA can crawl back into the deep and dark hole they appeared from.

iiNet are whinging about the cost of the case - but are happy to waste the courts time and money with this rubbish.!!!
Two-faced copmpany.
pete123
Nov 26, 2009 12:56 PM
Too right. These bloody industry associations should keep their collective noses out of this sort of thing. It's an issue between one private enterprise and ... oh ... hang on.
Rhino
Nov 26, 2009 1:03 PM
LOL @ Digger11 oh man the peace and serenity has been destroyed.

iiNet had nothing to do with IIA submitting to the courts, so the only people that could be seen as wasting time was IIA, not iiNet.

What you may not realise is that IIA also represents whatever internet provided you subscribe to. So go back and cry how you will never talk to Malone or Dalby ever again.
Sams
Nov 26, 2009 2:34 PM
Digger11; "Good - IIA can crawl back into the deep and dark hole they appeared from."

Right on - I mean, what would people like PIPE, Optus, Symantec, Telstra, Clayton Utz, D-Link, Ericsson, Facebook, Google, Vodafone, Rackspace, AusCERT, Microsoft, McAfee, AAPT, AARNet, Hutchison, etc. etc. know about the Internet and copyright law?? Oh wait ...
djzort
Nov 26, 2009 4:27 PM
Digger11 must be the one person that actually believes the film industry is some how hard done by.

At least all those stupid ads are convincing SOMEBODY.

anonymous
Nov 26, 2009 4:39 PM
Digger11 actually exists outside the stock library of the content corporations???
Johnny
Nov 26, 2009 7:31 PM
hey digger i think you've downloaded a copyrighted movie before - i have no proof, but im never wrong.

So by the way your thinking, i'm gonna contact your ISP and send them a notice and they'll disconnect you, so you can never ever troll again and download whatever disgusting crap gets you off becuase you don't have any (real) friends. Yeah i'd enjoy that system for getting pricks like you cut off :)

i've got something for the film industry:

if you are not making enough money then why are you still making movies when people go and download em for free?
and also you're not losing 20 bn per year, thats just a figure they've pulled out of their arse.
apaulefont
Nov 27, 2009 11:42 AM
I think if AFACT can provide the IP addresses of repeat offender accounts and iinet can match them up with the accounts, then i don't see a reason why copyright infringers shouldn't be disconnected. It doesn't seem like a difficult process to stop a crime that millions of people commit. It should be the account holders responsibility to ensure their home/business network is secure and all authorised users are prevented from downloading illegaly.
Sams
Nov 27, 2009 4:01 PM
apaulefont: "i don't see a reason why copyright infringers shouldn't be disconnected. It doesn't seem like a difficult process to stop a crime"

Do you see a problem with any of these:

1. Fred Bloggs reports you for being a child molester, and you get incarcerated without a trial?
2. Fred Bloggs reports you as being a terrorist and and your ISPs consequently reads all of you emails and intercepts your bank transactions to determine if its true. It turns out you weren't terrorist - oh well, your emails about your prostate problem were entertaining for the ISP staff party.
3. Assuming someone is guilty until proven innocent.

If you don't see a problem there, then perhaps you belong in a different country and a different time. Ethiopia might be right for you.
TruthSphere
Nov 27, 2009 6:24 PM
Digger11 you can't fool us, we are on this site because we are IT people, your opinions are laughable and uneducated.

I bet you absolutely are creaming over the idea of mandatory ISP filtering aswell..
apaulefont
Nov 30, 2009 12:28 PM
@ Sams

Obviously the ISP would need to use discretion in choosing which claims to investigate. The ISP would need to establish a relationship with the copyright holders and only act on claims of copyright infringment of their works.
Sams
Nov 30, 2009 12:51 PM
apaulefont: "Obviously the ISP would need to use discretion in choosing which claims to investigate. The ISP would need to establish a relationship with the copyright holders and only act on claims of copyright infringment of their works."

That would be open to a wide range of abuses:

1. "Obviously the ISP would need to use discretion in choosing which claims to investigate" - in other areas of law, such discretion is limited to authorised legal entities in Australia (e.g. federal police, customs officers, magistrates).

2. "only act on claims of copyright infringment of their works." - Aanyone that produces a 'work' (as defined in the copyright act - includes, text, images, video, computer code, etc. ...) is a copyright holder - it would be unfair to give special status to copyright holders that have the resources to cosy up to all of the ISPs.
anonymous
Nov 30, 2009 5:28 PM
@apaulefont, why should the operator of a toll road establish a relationship with copyright holders who purport to have information that some trucks using the tollway may be carrying loads of EPRs which could be used to record bootleg content?

You sound like another AFART troll.
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
Top Stories
ATO commits to complexity
Greater demand, fewer apps.
 
Photos: AusCERT 2013 day two
The second day of the Queensland security conference.
 
The illusion of cognitive computing
Opinion: IBM's Watson is a marketing success.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
To automatically deploy test/dev sandboxes by mid-year.
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Data safe with Human Services, CIO says.
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Technology chief shifts focus from building to leveraging systems.
VicRoads restructures IT team
VicRoads restructures IT team
Department moves to align with industry benchmarks.
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Malaysian staff served from Australian data centres.
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Yarra Valley Water CIO Leigh Berrell accepts his Benchmark Award for Utilities CIO of the Year.
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Domino's Pizza CIO Wayne McMahon accepts his Benchmark Award for Retail CIO of the Year.
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
CIO Jenny Levy discusses how outsourcing will help the firm "simplify, refocus and grow".
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Daniel McCabe, Assistant Secretary of Australia's Department of Defence, provides the audience at the iTnews Data Centre Strategy Summit with a deep dive into the organisation's data centre consolidation program.
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
The full keynote by Facebook data centre architect Marco Magarelli at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit. Magarelli details the design considerations behind the social network's Prineville, Oregon; North Carolina and Luleå, Sweden data centres.
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Telstra general manager of managed data centres Jon Curry guides the audience at the iTnews Australian Data Centre Summit through the build of the telco's Clayton, Victoria data centre.
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
Matthew Clark from the NSW Department of Environment guides facilties managers through the details of the new NABERS data centre energy rating tool at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit.
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
Matthew Clark (NSW Dept of Environment), Greg Boorer (Canberra Data Centres), Glenn Allan (National Australia Bank), Mike Andrea (Strategic Directions) and Bob Sharon (Green Global Consulting) discuss the impact of the NABERS data centre rating.
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Fortescue Metals 'New World of Work" project, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss the shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Pacific Aluminium's lightning fast service desk refresh, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Domino's Pizza's shift to hosted services, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss McDonald's Australia's new self-service portal for employees, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: ING Direct [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: ING Direct [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss ING Direct's 'Bank in a Box', one of three shortlisted finalists for the banking and finance category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Yarra Valley Water [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Yarra Valley Water [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Yarra Valley Water's insourcing project, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Utilities category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
HP's ElitePad 900: how it's different to the Surface Pro
May 23, 2013
Buying a tablet to use at work? These photos show why the HP ElitePad 900 G1 is an interesting ...
eftpos to trial "mobile wallet"
May 17, 2013
eftpos, the operator of Australia's most widely used debit card system will soon start a mobile ...
New iiNet 4G phone plans include free calls between phones on same account
May 16, 2013
iiNet's new 4G mobile business plans provide free calls between handsets on the same account as ...
Revealed: $1,000+ for Microsoft's Surface Pro in Australia, with keyboard
May 16, 2013
You'll pay more than $1,000 for Microsoft Surface Pro with a keyboard, Microsoft has officially ...
Is this the future of business laptops?
May 15, 2013
The Lenovo ThinkPad Helix is a fully-fledged business laptop running Windows 8 Pro, but detach ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Do you prefer the Coalition's NBN policy?

   |   View results
Yes
  19%
 
No
  81%
TOTAL VOTES: 1724

Vote