Day 21: IIA chief Peter Coroneos grilled on the stand in iiNet case

 

Film studios claim IIA adds nothing to iiNet copyright case.

Internet Industry Association chief Peter Coroneos has fronted a fiery cross-examination in the Federal Court today, as representatives of the world's major film studios attempted to portray the IIA’s application to enter the iiNet copyright case as providing “nothing new”.

Coroneos took the witness stand only after Justice Cowdroy turned down a proposal by the IIA's barristers requesting that he not be subject to cross-examination.

But Coroneos' brief appearance on the stand did not sate the film industry’s lead barrister Tony Bannon, who argued against the IIA's admission to proceedings.

“To satisfy the rule [to be admitted as a friend of the court], they’ve got to show there’s something new or different added [in their appearance],” Bannon told the court.

“There’s nothing new or different. It’s the same words [as the iiNet submissions] by a new hand.”

Earlier, Bannon had pinned Coroneos to the stand on the issue of whether he personally had reviewed iiNet’s submissions before making his own to the court.

“Are you familiar with the written submissions the IIA filed with the court?” Bannon put to Coroneos.

“Yes,” Coroneos replied.

“And you’re familiar with the iiNet submissions filed with the court?” Bannon asked.

“I think we’ve been provided with copies. I can’t say I read them all in detail,” Coroneos replied.

“Are you able to answer this question - are you able to identify a single paragraph of the IIA submissions which addresses a subject matter not already covered in the iiNet submissions?” Bannon pressed, raising his voice considerably.

The IIA’s senior counsel Stephen Burley objected, prompting Bannon to withdraw - but rephrase - the question. That drew a further objection from Burley, with Justice Cowdroy intervening to clarify with Coroneos directly.

“I believe the perspective we seek agreement on goes beyond the perspective I understand iiNet has been arguing,” Coroneos said in response. “We seek to provide the court in our submissions a broader view on how this case may affect members of the internet industry.”

“But so I can understand it, you didn’t undertake to check first whether a single one of those submissions had not been dealt with in iiNet’s submission?” Bannon responded.

Burley objected a third time, saying the question was “irrelevant”.

Bannon continued.

“He hasn’t undertaken personally whether anything he’s said in writing hasn’t been dealt with in written submissions by iiNet? I want it on the record.”

Burley pointed out that the iiNet submissions were not available to the association at the time the IIA drafted its affidavit.

“I think that raises a factual issue,” Justice Cowdroy agreed. “I don’t think your question is going to go very far,” he told Bannon.

“We’ve looked through their submissions. It looks the same as what iiNet already said,” Bannon responded. “It doesn’t satisfy the rules [for amicus curae].”

“Are you referring to any submissions?” Justice Cowdroy asked Bannon. “In other words, there’s nothing new in the IIA submissions?”

“That would be our submission,” Bannon replied.

The battle continued even after Coroneos left the stand, with Bannon labelling as "absurd" parts of Burley's oral submissions to the court.

Justice Cowdroy reserved his decision on the application until 10.15am on Thursday.

The case continues.


Day 21: IIA chief Peter Coroneos grilled on the stand in iiNet case
 
 
 
Top Stories
ATO investigates 25 tech giants in tax hunt
Prepared to take tax evaders to court.
 
Immigration, Customs restructure IT leadership
Customs CIO promoted into transformation role.
 
NBN Co begins FTTB rollout
Will bring service to 6000 apartments.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Franchisees, here's something you should know about
Jan 23, 2015
You need to know the Code if you are a franchisee or franchisor as the penalties are significant.
Xero users rejoice! Quoting has finally arrived
Jan 23, 2015
It has taken years, but Xero has at last added integrated quoting to its online accounting software.
You can now get a no-contract wi-fi tablet from Telstra
Jan 17, 2015
Telstra has began selling wi-fi tablets out of contract without paying extra for cellular ...
Get your business ready for 2015: mobile payments
Jan 2, 2015
These handy apps from MYOB, Xero and others can reduce your administrative load and improve ...
Xero prepares for key feature coming in 2015
Dec 19, 2014
Xero users will be able to track how their business is comparing to other Xero users.
Latest Comments
Polls
Who do you trust most to protect your private data?







   |   View results
Your bank
  36%
 
Your insurance company
  5%
 
A technology company (Google, Facebook et al)
  9%
 
Your telco, ISP or utility
  8%
 
A retailer (Coles, Woolworths et al)
  4%
 
A Federal Government agency (ATO, Centrelink etc)
  18%
 
An Australian law enforcement agency (AFP, ASIO et al)
  14%
 
A State Government agency (Health dept, etc)
  7%
TOTAL VOTES: 2926

Vote
Do you support the abolition of the Office of the Information Commissioner?

   |   View results
I support shutting down the OAIC.
  27%
 
I DON'T support shutting the OAIC.
  73%
TOTAL VOTES: 908

Vote