Day 21: iiNet sample users didn’t take up quota offers

 

Customers not scared by the prospect of shaping.

ISP iiNet’s sample of 20 customer accounts surfaced in the copyright case showed there was “no correlation” between infringing activity and download quotas, the Federal Court heard today.

As the case resumed, iiNet’s lead barrister Richard Cobden provided a brief analysis of the accounts in his closing address in an attempt to dispute the studio’s assertion that iiNet was encouraging infringement on its network by offering customers upgrades to higher-capacity plans.

The upgrades would allow users to download more illegal copies of films because they would avoid being shaped (having their transfer speeds reduced), the studios had alleged.

In his analysis, Cobden said that user "RC01" used only half of its allocated quota in June. Another, "RC05" used 23 percent of its quota in October, 2008.

Cobden said that of the accounts sampled, “15 were shaped at some point during the year”. He said 10 upgraded to higher download quotas over the year but there was “no correlation” between the upgrade and the users wanting to download the applicant’s films.

“And one of them downgraded [during the year], which is inconsistent with the applicant’s assertion,” Cobden said.

“We’re not suggesting it’s excusable for somebody to download these films [illegally]. What it does demonstrate is that when offered an upgrade, they’re not taking it to download more of the applicant’s films.”

Cobden said that telling customers when they were approaching their quota limit for the month was a “business service” offered by iiNet that enabled them to either budget their remaining quota for the month or upgrade to prevent being shaped.

The case continues. You can follow the case in-full here. For a background on the case, click here.


Day 21: iiNet sample users didn’t take up quota offers
 
 
 
Top Stories
NBN to offer TV connections through fibre for greenfields
Ditching aerials to come at a cost.
 
Tech SWAT teams kicking down the digital door
From dam engineers in Ecuador to Sydney light-rail gurus, Cardno's global CIO Karen Wagner is linking up her widespread organisation.
 
AusPost board approves Fujitsu outsourcing
End user computing to be handed over to partner.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Xerocon is heading to Melbourne!
Jul 1, 2015
We're not saying Xero is our FAVOURITE or anything, but Xero's 2015 Xerocon conference is being ...
New Microsoft Office apps for Android phones
Jun 26, 2015
Microsoft's latest Office apps for Android now work on phones as well as tablets, further ...
Windows 10 UK price revealed, but don't believe everything you hear
Jun 26, 2015
Windows 10 £99 price tag for users in the UK (who presumably don't already have Win 7 Pro ...
Now Xero notifies iOS users of new transactions
Jun 24, 2015
The latest version of Xero's iPhone app includes notifications when new transactions arrive from ...
Your Essential Cloud Toolbox
Jun 22, 2015
When BIT interviewed Receipt Bank country manager Sophie Hossack, we asked for her thoughts on ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Is site blocking effective in stopping piracy?


   |   View results
Yes
  2%
 
No
  85%
 
Somewhat
  13%
TOTAL VOTES: 661

Vote