RIAA stung by wrongfully accused 'pirate'

 

Defendant to get 'reasonable fees' as RIAA case collapses.

The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has been hit by a legal mistake that could see it paying out substantial legal fees. 

The recording industry lobby group initiated action in November 2004 against Oklahoma housewife Debbie Foster, alleging that her IP address had been used to download music illegally.

Foster denied the claims but admitted that her husband and daughter also had access to the computer.

The RIAA then filed suit against Foster's daughter Amanda, and won the case since Amanda failed to defend herself.

The filing included Debbie Foster as the RIAA felt that she was still liable for secondary copyright infringement as she owned the account.

Foster responded by filing a claim of her own for "declaratory judgement of noninfringement".

A year and a half after filing the original claim the RIAA dropped its case, but Foster refused to drop hers.

Judge Lee R. West found that Foster was liable to sue the RIAA for attorney's fees, thought to be around US$50,000, because she had not encouraged or even known about the fraud.

"The Copyright Act does not expressly render anyone liable for infringement committed by another. Rather, the doctrine of secondary liability emerged from common law principles," wrote Judge West.

"Under those common law principles, one infringes a copyright contributorily by intentionally inducing or encouraging a direct infringement."

Since there was no evidence of Debbie Foster encouraging the use of peer-to-peer downloads, the judge found that she had no case to answer and was free to recoup her costs.

Copyright ©v3.co.uk


RIAA stung by wrongfully accused 'pirate'
 
 
 
Top Stories
Westpac committed to core banking plan
[Blog post] Now with leadership.
 
The True Cost of BYOD - 2014 survey
Twelve months on from our first study, is BYOD a better proposition?
 
Photos: Unboxing the Magnus supercomputer
Pawsey's biggest beast slots into place.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest Comments
Polls
What is delaying adoption of public cloud in your organisation?







   |   View results
Lock-in concerns
  29%
 
Application integration concerns
  3%
 
Security and compliance concerns
  27%
 
Unreliable network infrastructure
  9%
 
Data sovereignty concerns
  22%
 
Lack of stakeholder support
  3%
 
Protecting on-premise IT jobs
  4%
 
Difficulty transitioning CapEx budget into OpEx
  3%
TOTAL VOTES: 1154

Vote