iiTrial: AFACT grilled on 'reasonable steps' for iiNet

 

Business models pursued by content owners questioned.

The Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft (AFACT) has faced tough questions from three of five High Court Justices over the efficacy of an ISP warning its users of alleged copyright infringements.

AFACT counsel Tony Bannon argued iiNet breached the authorisation provisions of s 101(1A) of the Copyright Act because it did not take "reasonable steps" to prevent acts of infringement by users.

He further argued that even if iiNet had warned a user in response to an AFACT notice, that it may not be "sufficient to avoid a breach of authorisation, if the ISP did not follow up how an alleged infringer had responded" to that warning.

The term "sufficient" provoked an exchange between Bannon and Justice William Gummow.

MR BANNON:  ... we certainly maintained that a warning notice was an appropriate step.

GUMMOW J: But not a sufficient step.

MR BANNON: In the first instance.

GUMMOW J: No, no, not a sufficient step.

MR BANNON: It would depend on the outcome of the step.

GUMMOW J: Exactly, so it is not a sufficient step.

MR BANNON: But it may be a sufficient step.

GUMMOW J: May or may not be. Therefore, it is not.

Justice Gummow also mused why AFACT could not have used discovery orders to connect the client numbers with the client details and pursue remedies directly.

“…If you had done that you could have made an example of a few users which might have had an impact on others,” Gummow said.

Content conundrums

Justices Kenneth Hayne and Susan Crennan raised further questions of whether ther were any reasonable steps open to an ISP to prevent - in the face of evidence - widespread copyright infringement occuring on the internet.

“The conundrum is the power that the ISP has, the steps that the ISP can take depend ultimately for their effect on the individual user’s choice, for all that the ISP can do is switch off,” Hayne said.

Bannon responded that iiNet should at least take a step of sending warning notices.

"We never said that would necessarily be enough... we have not got to that situation yet, but we could not dictate - and if one comes down to the form of a court order, if it was a mandatory order, the court could not dictate - the form of a notice to a client, a customer of an internet service provider," he said.

Alternative business models by the film and TV studios also surfaced as a form of prevention, floated by Justice Crennan.

“Is not the real conundrum lying behind all of this that in an ideal world, for the copyright owners, everyone who wants to watch a film will go and pay $30 for the DVD?," Crennan asked.

She noted it only cost a few cents to download which explains why infringement is rife.

"So that it is very difficult... just by referring to an obligation to send notices, to get some efficacy into the sending of the notices or to get the balance right between the stake of the copyright owners in what is happening and duties on the service providers?”

Justice Crennan speculated a royalty arrangement with regular audits regarding infringement was worth consideration.

"The truth is that users who want to download films would not mind their service charges increasing by a margin in order to do that lawfully. That seems to me to be the very large conundrum that is at the heart of this case.”

iiNet CEO still positive

At the end of the first day of proceedings, iiNet CEO Michael Malone said he was confident the High Court would reaffirm and strengthen the Federal Court's earlier judgments, clearing the company of authorising copyright breaches.

Speaking to ITnews, Malone said that the local evidence in favour of the efficacy of warning notices was slight.

“Exetel was the only ISP I was aware of that was forwarding notices to their customers. If I recall correctly when we won the case they stopped doing it,” Malone said.

He said he disputed evidence that iiNet’s subsidiary Westnet had a track record of distributing the warning notices without problems.

“The Westnet example involved a few hundred notices over seven years - all done manually.”

He said it was not an effective scheme.

He added that Exetel’s scheme had been a web page presented when an alleged infringer next logged in to use the internet.

“Don’t do it again, click here if you agree - and that was it. There was no formal follow-up,” Malone said.

"iiNet has never in any way supported or encouraged breaches of the law, including breaches of the Copyright Act."

Malone urged the film industry to increase lawful online content in a more timely, affordable and competitively-priced manner. He said that was the best method to protect content owners' copyrights.

The case continues today. The full transcript of the first day’s proceedings can be found here. 

Stay tuned to iTnews for up-to-the-minute coverage of the iiNet vs AFACT High Court Appeal from our reporter on the ground.

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


iiTrial: AFACT grilled on 'reasonable steps' for iiNet
Scales of Justice
 
 
 
Top Stories
Frugality as a service: the Amazon story
Behind the scenes, Amazon Web Services is one lean machine.
 
Negotiating with the cloud email megavendors
[Blog post] Lessons from Woolworths’ mammoth migration.
 
Qld govt to move up to 149k staff onto Office 365
Australia's largest deployment, outside of the universities.
 
 
Scales of Justice
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

The great data centre opportunity on Australia's doorstep
The great data centre opportunity on Australia's doorstep
Scott Noteboom, CEO of LitBit speaking at The Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit 2014 in the Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia. http://bit.ly/1qpxVfV Scott Noteboom is a data centre engineer who led builds for Apple and Yahoo in the earliest days of the cloud, and who now eyes Asia as the next big opportunity. Read more: http://www.itnews.com.au/News/372482,how-do-we-serve-three-billion-new-internet-users.aspx#ixzz2yNLmMG5C
Interview: Karl Maftoum, CIO, ACMA
Interview: Karl Maftoum, CIO, ACMA
To COTS or not to COTS? iTnews asks Karl Maftoum, CIO of the ACMA, at the CIO Strategy Summit.
Susan Sly: What is the Role of the CIO?
Susan Sly: What is the Role of the CIO?
AEMO chief information officer Susan Sly calls for more collaboration among Australia's technology leaders at the CIO Strategy Summit.
Meet the 2014 Finance CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Finance CIO of the Year
Credit Union Australia's David Gee awarded Finance CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards.
Meet the 2014 Retail CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Retail CIO of the Year
Damon Rees named Retail CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at Woolworths.
Robyn Elliott named the 2014 Utilities CIO of the Year
Robyn Elliott named the 2014 Utilities CIO of the Year
Acting Foxtel CIO David Marks accepts an iTnews Benchmark Award on behalf of Robyn Elliott.
Meet the 2014 Industrial CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Industrial CIO of the Year
Sanjay Mehta named Industrial CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at ConocoPhillips.
Meet the 2014 Healthcare CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Healthcare CIO of the Year
Greg Wells named Healthcare CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at NSW Health.
Meet the 2014 Education CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Education CIO of the Year
William Confalonieri named Healthcare CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at Deakin University.
Meet the 2014 Government CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Government CIO of the Year
David Johnson named Government CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at the Queensland Police Service.
Q and A: Coalition Broadband Policy
Q and A: Coalition Broadband Policy
Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott discuss the Coalition's broadband policy with the press.
AFP scalps hacker 'leader' inside Australia's IT ranks.
AFP scalps hacker 'leader' inside Australia's IT ranks.
The Australian Federal Police have arrested a Sydney-based IT security professional for hacking a government website.
NBN Petition Delivered To Turnbull's Office
NBN Petition Delivered To Turnbull's Office
UTS CIO: IT teams of the future
UTS CIO: IT teams of the future
UTS CIO Chrissy Burns talks data.
New UTS Building: the IT within
New UTS Building: the IT within
The IT behind tomorrow's universities.
iTnews' NBN Panel
iTnews' NBN Panel
Is your enterprise NBN-ready?
Introducing iTnews Labs
Introducing iTnews Labs
See a timelapse of the iTnews labs being unboxed, set up and switched on! iTnews will produce independent testing of the latest enterprise software to hit the market after installing a purpose-built test lab in Sydney. Watch the installation of two DL380p servers, two HP StoreVirtual 4330 storage arrays and two HP ProCurve 2920 switches.
The True Cost of BYOD
The True Cost of BYOD
iTnews' Brett Winterford gives attendees of the first 'Touch Tomorrow' event in Brisbane a brief look at his research into enterprise mobility. What are the use cases and how can they be quantified? What price should you expect to pay for securing mobile access to corporate applications? What's coming around the corner?
Ghost clouds
Ghost clouds
ACMA chair Chris Chapman says there is uncertainty over whether certain classes of cloud service providers are caught by regulations.
Was the Snowden leak inevitable?
Was the Snowden leak inevitable?
Privacy experts David Vaile (UNSW Cyberspace Law and Policy Centre) and Craig Scroggie (CEO, NextDC) claim they were not surprised by the Snowden leaks about the NSA's PRISM program.
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Another phone with Telstra's Blue Tick: The Samsung Galaxy S5
Apr 8, 2014
Samsung's latest flagship phone joins Telstra's list of recommended handsets for customers in ...
Run an online shop? This might be worth bookmarking
Mar 28, 2014
Things like Australian safety standards are probably the last thing on your mind, but just ...
Vodafone switches on 4G in Tasmania: list of locations
Mar 28, 2014
See a list of locations in Tasmania that now have access to 4G via Vodafone's network.
Samsung Galaxy S5 on sale from Telstra next month for $912
Mar 27, 2014
It's not cheap, but if you are looking to upgrade your phone then the Samsung Galaxy S5 could be ...
What Australian workplaces actually rely on tablet computers?
Mar 14, 2014
If you're curious about where tablets are being used at work, here are three examples.
Latest Comments
Polls
Which bank is most likely to suffer an RBS-style meltdown?





   |   View results
ANZ
  21%
 
Bankwest
  9%
 
CommBank
  11%
 
National Australia Bank
  17%
 
Suncorp
  24%
 
Westpac
  19%
TOTAL VOTES: 1455

Vote