Tasmanian public schools locked out of NBN

 

By their existing contracts and security concerns.

Tasmania's Department of Education has neutered criticism from the state's opposition over public school takeup of the NBN, revealing all schools in trial areas were serving out existing telecommunications contracts.

A department spokeman told iTnews that public schools were obliged to acquire telecommunications service through a whole-of-government contract that had run since 2007.

Although initially set to expire last year, the Tasmanian Government had renewed the contract until 2013.

The extension effectively prevented public schools in the state from signing up for NBN access.

Instead, they were obliged to procure services from Telstra, Aurora Energy or BBW.

Shadow education minister Michael Ferguson slammed state Labor earlier this week after it was confirmed that no public schools in the current NBN serving areas of Smithton, Scottsdale or Midway Point had fibre access to all classrooms.

In written answers [pdf] provided to Ferguson and published on his site, education minister Nick McKim said that the only NBN access at public schools was an Internode-supplied trial classroom at Smithon High School.

"The benefits of being the first part of the country with the NBN are slipping away as the mainland roll-out commences, yet the Green-Labor Government has done nothing," Ferguson said in a statement accompanying the answers.

Digital Tasmania spokesman Andrew O'Connor supported Ferguson's pressing of the issue.

Security needs

A Department of Premier and Cabinet spokesman told iTnews that there were also some technical considerations before public schools could join the NBN.

"Issues such as filtering of inappropriate content and viruses and access to the secure Government network are important pre-requisites which need to be covered before those schools can move to the NBN," he said in a statement.

But Digital Tasmania's O'Connor argued the state government had "two years to prepare for this but haven't gotten that far".

"Obviously security and access to those networks are paramount but certainly this could have all been arranged int he last year and you could go further to think that they knew the NBN was coming a year before that," he told iTnews.

"Essentially they've had two years to prepare for this but haven't gotten that far."

On-boarding with NBN Co

State education minister Nick McKim argued that more extensive fibre connections to public classrooms would not occur until "the State Government Wide Area Network communications providers became registered with NBN Co as retail service providers".

Telstra is both a state government contract partner and, since September last year, has trialled NBN services in the state.

A Telstra spokesman said the trial continued with a "small number of customers". 

He would not confirm whether Telstra would offer commercial services to premises in the state in the near future.

It is believed Aurora Energy, which also acts as agent for NBN Co's Tasmanian subsidiary, is in negotiations to become a retail service provider on the network but is yet to finalise negotiations to on-board with the government wholesaler as a provider.

The education department's deputy secretary of corporate services Andrew Finch said that Aurora Energy was "working closely with the Government" on the issue.

The telco had previously held discussions with the Federal Government to form a joint venture with NBN Co, but negotiations reportedly fell apart.

NBN-connected schools

Circular Head Christian School in Smithton has been highlighted as one of few schools having received the technology so far.

It was used as the site for the official launch of the NBN in Tasmania last year, and connected via the internet to students at the Presbyterian Ladies College in Armidale in May as an example of the types of applications that the broadband network could facilitate.

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


Tasmanian public schools locked out of NBN
"(Sigh) @advocate has sniped at every positive NBN article for the past year, so he knows the answers to both his questions. For those who don't: 1. The borrowings comprise about $27 billion by ..."
By umbria
 
 
 
Comments: 10
Rossyduck
Jun 16, 2011 4:41 PM
I thought one of the key reasons for the NBN and government spending my tax $$ was to provide service to all these neglected underserved schools ? .... Take the school pupils out and NBN Co truly have more staff than customers. Suppose that is why they need taxpayer funding to poach Greenfields and buy Telstra customers - something we as taxpeyers were not contributing a cent to in the past? Maybe a better use of our taxes would be to employ very highly paid door knockers to cajole people to sign up for centerlink benefits ?
Ace
Jun 16, 2011 8:10 PM
You must have neglected to read the article @Rossyduck. If you had, you would note that that in fact there is no indication in the article that schools are 'locked out' as the heading suggests. Instead, it says schools had existing contracts that run until 2013. This probably works out well, as of course the NBN rollout is a progressive thing, and it gives various players time to formulate policy around access, price etc etc.

The whole thing about security is obviously a furphy.... unless they are seriously trying to suggest their current internet connections do not need security, but NBN connections do?
deepthroat
Jun 17, 2011 9:03 AM
@Rossyduck - I agree. Something that the NBN fans on this site - like @Ace fail to grasp is getting value for our tax dollars. We need to be gentle with them, after all they have grown (up?)on a diet of - buy it now and pay later. Those of us that have tasted a little more life realise that LATER actually does arrive and you do really need to pay it back.
anonymous
Jun 17, 2011 1:46 PM

@Ace - I agree. Something that NBN deniers on this site fail to grasp is that NBN will operate for many years, and will be self-funding as usage fees will pay the borrowing costs.

So all the crocodile tears about taxpayers are baseless. People who don't want the NBN because it may change their business model, or are opposed because the 'wrong' side of politics is backing it, are fully entitled to express their views. And the rest of us are entitled to respond as we see fit.
Ace
Jun 17, 2011 4:21 PM
I see @deepthroats point. He/she is obviously in his/her late 50s/early 60s(?), where of course the future is all a little shorter, and things need to be paid off before retirement. While I sympathise with this, and I'm not that far behind (age-wise), I do recognise that the future carries on regardless of whether I am there or not. My children are a constant reminder of this. I recognise that it's probably more them than me who need an NBN. If my tax dollars now are going to help my children in the future, well that's great. Remember, it's all about the children @deepthroat :)
umbria
Jun 17, 2011 8:13 PM
@deepthroat knows perfectly well that his tax dollars are not building the NBN. Its construction (fibre, wireless, two satellites and some backhaul) is being funded by borrowings for the purpose, which will be repaid by NBNCo from its wholesale revenues. No budget program is being cut to fund the NBN.

Who will be surprised when the imminent announcement of the successful conclusion of the NBNCo-Telstra contract is accompanied by news that the balance of the Telstra contract for these schools will be delivered over NBN fibre?
HubertCumberdale
Jun 17, 2011 8:59 PM
There is no point in reasoning with someone like that guys, just remember you are dealing with someone who thinks the government should pay for their groceries and kids shoes because they dont know how to manage money spending it on cigarettes and alcohol as well as gambling... I assume.
advocate
Jun 18, 2011 11:21 AM
umbria wrote:
@deepthroat knows perfectly well that his tax dollars are not building the NBN. Its construction (fibre, wireless, two satellites and some backhaul) is being funded by borrowings for the purpose, which will be repaid by NBNCo from its wholesale revenues. No budget program is being cut to fund the NBN.

I keep asking the same questions and you keep ignoring them by just repeating the same worn mantra straight from the NBN spin machine hymn book:

1. What 'borrowings' are funding the NBN?
2. What revenue is the NBN making that actually even pays for the paper for their photo copying machine?



Edited by advocate: 18/6/2011 11:22:17 AM
Rizz
Jun 18, 2011 3:22 PM
Hi advocate/alain...

I've been resisting coming here, but WTH!

Why don't YOU tell us all where the money is coming from since you reject umbria's claims!
umbria
Jun 18, 2011 4:18 PM
(Sigh) @advocate has sniped at every positive NBN article for the past year, so he knows the answers to both his questions. For those who don't:

1. The borrowings comprise about $27 billion by the government on NBNCo's behalf until it turns cashflow-positive, after which NBNCo will raise $8 billion. All borrowings plus any interest will be repaid by NBNCo from its wholesale revenues.

2. NBNCo's costs to date are funded from seed funds, not wholesale revenue. NBNCo is an access wholesaler, therefore its revenues commence when it starts billing retail service providers for access. This is expected to be in September (unless the pilot in Tasmania is already using the final billing - I don't know whether it is yet). As you also know, NBNCo published revenue forecasts last December in its 2011-2013 COrporate Plan, available at nbnco.com.au

Finally, every month that Malcolm Turnbull delays services is another month added to the time the loans can be repaid. He has also directly cost taxpayers a fortune (I estimate in the region of one billion dollars) for his frivolous use of parliamentary resources including overnight and extra sitting day expenses, accommodation, travel allowances and forfeited airfares. His opposition to the NBN is entirely party political, as he knows the choice of FTTP wherever possible is the best technology, supports universal Wi-Fi and wireless, and that FTTP is also CHEAPER than ALL alternatives that are capable of delivering 12 Mbps or better to the 93% of premises that are to be fibred.

Watch the news next week. When the Telstra deal is announced, I tip that the Tassie schools will almost certainly see the balance of their Bigpond broadband contracts delivered on NBN fibre, with Telstra as the RSP. A win for all parties (except the Luddites).
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
 
Top Stories
CommBank suppliers compete for portable workloads
Multi-sourcing deals yield $100m savings.
 
Australia turns to homegrown drones
Debating the finer points of unmanned aerial vehicle design.
 
The New Zealand telco problem
Opinion: Could Telstra save Kiwi telcos?
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Should the Government enact new legislation to protect copyright holders in the digital age?

   |   View results
Yes
  20%
 
No
  80%
TOTAL VOTES: 529

Vote