CA sues over DB2 migration tool

By Ry Crozier on Nov 26, 2010 6:00 AM
Filed under Software

Disputes claims its database platform is "dying".

EXCLUSIVE: Software giant CA has filed suit against a Sydney software developer over a program that allegedly enabled companies to migrate off CA database platforms onto IBM DB2.

CA alleged that developer ISI Software infringed copyright when creating the 2BDB2 tool to assist Macquarie Bank's transition off CA's Datacom database between 1996 and 1998.

The tool was allegedly created by Macquarie Bank staff and an ISI contractor.

CA alleged that the bank then allowed ISI to commercially "exploit" 2BDB2 from about August 1999.

CA claimed ISI's software "reproduced" portions of confidential source and object codes without permission and deprived CA of license fees.

CA alleged that it had lost revenue from former database customers that had incorrectly stopped paying license fees when they started using the ISI tool.

The software giant claimed it was not possible to use ISI's software without relying on portions of CA code that the vendor said required a license to use.

CA sought court orders to "permanently restrain" ISI and award damages and profits it claimed would be "unconscionable" for ISI to keep.

The vendor also took issue with ISI's positioning of CA's database platforms in website and marketing materials, which allegedly began with the words, "Is your legacy data stuck in CA-Datacom?"

CA alleged that ISI represented to customers that CA programs were "dying".

The vendor disputed that its database platforms were "dying".

ISI admitted in its defence it used the "dying" reference once in an email but said it was retracted immediately afterwards.

ISI Software either denied or did not admit to any of CA's allegations in a defence statement filed with the court.

The accused company also said it would seek to "rely at trial on the license agreement [between Macquarie Bank and CA Pacific] for its full terms and effect". It did not provide further details.

In a directions hearing this week, the parties were directed to file and serve affidavit evidence "in chief" by March 15, 2011.

The case was listed for further directions in June 2011.

3 comments in this discussion

"So considering the tools been out since at least 1998, I hope someone at CA's been fired for sitting on their hands over this for 12 odd years. Otherwise, why bring this up now?"

By Ezy2Confuze

Tags

ca, computer associates, ibm, db2, isi, software, federal, court, copyright, infringement

CA to amend claim against Sydney developer

TPG scrapes out of $2 million fine

Feds tip ACTA analysis by year end

IBM to open Ballarat software testing centre

Breaking Stories

Alacer Gold turns ERP refit project to Australia

NSW Govt bids for self-service analytics

NSW Police take aim at 3D-printable guns

Google faces new federal antitrust probe

US ISP to rip out Huawei equipment

Readers of this article also read...

Comments: 3

NotesTracker - Tony Austin Nov 26, 2010 11:49 AM	Once used in an an email but retracted immediately afterwards? ... Not factual! I just did a Google search for the phrase "Is your legacy data stuck in CA-Datacom?" and found it elsewhere. For example, you can see it right now at http://www.2bdb2.com/home.cfm?s=1 (immediately below the digram "2BDB2 Suite of Products").
WanderingBear Nov 26, 2010 1:42 PM	Tony, Whilst your extensive Google search did indeed find that phrase, the point discussed was the reference to the "dying" statement in an email once. I cannot find any such reference to such an assertion on the web paged you linked to, so what what are you saying is not factual?
Ezy2Confuze Nov 29, 2010 4:57 PM	So considering the tools been out since at least 1998, I hope someone at CA's been fired for sitting on their hands over this for 12 odd years. Otherwise, why bring this up now?