ISP Beagle says half of TIO effort wasted

 

Neutral outcomes balloon.

ISP Beagle Internet has claimed that half of the energy expended by the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman (TIO) resulted in "no useful outcome" to the ISP or consumer.

In a submission [pdf] to the communications regulator's Reconnecting the Customer inquiry, Beagle Internet launched a scathing attack on the TIO, claiming its figures were grossly inflated and that it was in the financial interests of the ombudsman to report high statistics.

A TIO spokesman declined to comment specifically on the allegations.

"Given that Beagle Internet's submission is to a public inquiry being conducted by the ACMA, it is not appropriate for the TIO to make any public comment on the submission," the spokesman said.

"The TIO has also lodged its submission to the ACMA inquiry and it is available for public viewing on the ACMA website."

Beagle Internet joined other telcos including AAPT in claiming that TIO figures were inflated by the way the organisation counted complaints lodged with it.

The ISP claimed that a "single complaint could be counted up to as many as eight complaints in the statistics published in the TIO Annual Reports."

"This occurs because the TIO re-bills complaints each quarter if they take more than three months to process and then double, tipple [sic] or even quadruple counts complaints if they are escalated in level classification," the ISP said.

"At a worst case, this represents an over-inflation of complaint numbers in the order of thousands."

Beagle was also critical of the TIO over its decision to stop publishing the outcomes of complaints that were investigated at escalated levels 2-4 in its annual report.

"The TIO ceased publishing these key metrics in 2008 and curiously has not responded to our enquiries as to why this has occurred," Beagle said.

The ISP said that the results from 2005 to 2007 saw a doubling in the number of complaints with a "neutral outcome"; that is, one where the outcome favoured neither the complainant nor the ISP.

"A neutral outcome gives a clear indication that the complaint before the TIO did not represent a true unresolved dispute or a failure on the part of the member [ISP]," Beagle said.

"Indeed, it is likely that such matters represent events or issues that should not have been brought before the TIO at all.

"Further, this [sic] statistics indicates that essentially 50 percent of the effort expended by TIO resources results in no useful outcome to either the member or the consumer.

"As the scheme itself costs members many tens millions of dollars per year to run, if over 50 percent of complaints are delivering neutral outcomes, there are significant questions to be answered regarding the cost-effectiveness and quality of the scheme from both a structural and implementation perspective."

Among Beagle's other criticisms was that the TIO suffered a "conflict of interest by virtue of its funding model".

"The TIO receives 100 percent of its revenue from processing individual complaints levied against its members," Beagle said.

"The very existence of the TIO (including continuity of employment for its staff), and the perception of its relevance and reputation in the regulatory environment relies solely upon maintaining and increasing the number of complaints it receives from consumers.

"Unlike other alternate dispute resolution schemes or tribunals, the TIO engages in active advertising campaigns to attract new complaints and undertakes no ongoing programs to actively reduce the number of complaints or improve the quality of complaint classification and analysis to reduce the enormous number of neutral outcomes.

"This conflict of interest therefore undermines the independence of the scheme and places a question mark upon some of the policy, practice and published metrics of the TIO," the ISP claimed.

Beagle called for reform of the funding model but did not propose an alternative in its submission.

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


ISP Beagle says half of TIO effort wasted
 
 
 
Top Stories
CIO exits as Coles steps up offshoring
Updated: Engages Accenture in Manila; staff to learn of their fate today.
 
Matching databases to Linux distros
Reviewed: OS-repository DBMSs, MariaDB vs MySQL.
 
Coalition's NBN cost-benefit study finds in favour of MTM
FTTP costs too much, would take too long.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Looking for storage? Seagate has five new small business NAS devices
Aug 22, 2014
Seagate has announced a new portfolio of Networked Attached Storage (NAS) solutions specifically ...
Run a small business in western Sydney?
Aug 15, 2014
This event might be of interest if you're looking to meet other people with a similar interest ...
Buying a tablet? Microsoft's Surface Pro 3 goes on sale this month
Aug 8, 2014
Microsoft has announced its Surface Pro 3 will go on sale in Australia on 28 August from ...
Apple's top MacBook Pro with Retina is now cheaper
Aug 1, 2014
Apple has updated its MacBook Pro range with faster processors and new pricing, including ...
Pass on carbon tax savings, warns ACCC
Jul 24, 2014
The ACCC is warning businesses that supply "regulated goods" to pass on any cost savings ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Which is the most prevalent cyber attack method your organisation faces?




   |   View results
Phishing and social engineering
  71%
 
Advanced persistent threats
  3%
 
Unpatched or unsupported software vulnerabilities
  11%
 
Denial of service attacks
  6%
 
Insider threats
  10%
TOTAL VOTES: 792

Vote