Telstra-NBN Co agreement no surety: ISPs

 

Mixed reaction to $11 billion agreement.

Internet service providers including iPrimus, Internode and Exetel labelled yesterday's $11 billion agreement between NBN Co and Telstra everything from a victory to a backwards step for the industry.

A poll of ISPs conducted by iTnews revealed the difference in opinions, underscored in part by the lack of detail surrounding the financial heads of agreement.

Telstra have conceded that it will be at least the "first half of 2011" before definitive deals are reached and put to shareholders.

"The heads of agreement provides the framework for definitive agreements to be negotiated over the coming months," Telstra said in a statement.

Analyst group Ovum noted today that while an agreement might be good news for Telstra, it wasn't necessarily so for competing ISPs.

"For the rest of the industry, this makes the future of the NBN Co more secure, but also makes Telstra into the NBN Co's most important customer," said Ovum analyst David Kennedy.

"Telstra and the NBN Co's interests are lining up, and Telstra's competitors should be wary."

Critics

Exetel chief John Linton told iTnews that if the ALP wasn't re-elected at the next federal election - something he believed to be "at least a possibility" - then the agreement meant "nothing at all."

"If it does go ahead, then it would appear to be a good thing on the basis that it’s difficult to believe that any national infrastructure wholesaler could be as bad as Telstra," Linton said.

"However it also means there is no fibre choice in Australia just as there was no copper choice and, I thought Australia privatised Telecom Australia because a government monopoly was horrendously inefficient. So... back to where Australian communications was 20 years ago?"

"We would have preferred Telstra to have remained as a competitor to NBN Co."

Internode chief Simon Hackett called the announcement a "press release, not a real agreement".

Hackett also criticised the Government's decision to allow Telstra to bid for Long Term Evolution (LTE) spectrum, even without committing to structurally separate.

"That seems, to me, to be a pretty big backdown from the Government, that calls into question the Government's resolve to ensure that Telstra do separate as part of the NBN being built," he said.

"It is vital that this happens to ensure the results are competitively positive for consumers."

Telstra told journalists earlier today that it had not managed to have structural separation moved off the table completely.

"Functional separation is not entirely off the table," the telco's chief financial officer John Stanhope said.

"It may be a condition that is necessary later on but in this current financial heads of agreement it's not one of the current points [required of Telstra]."

Commendations

Ravi Bhatia, chief executive at iPrimus was more positive, noting that the agreement paved the way to pass legislation required to build the national broadband network.

“At the end of the day the legislation is stuck in parliament as Telstra and the Liberal party opposed it," Bhatia said.

"At least Telstra's opposition [now] goes away.”

The agreement also represented a "huge positive for Telstra's bottom line", Bhatia said.

But it was "essential the money is used to recompense Telstra shareholders, especially the T2 shareholders, who paid a very high price for the Telstra stock, which is now languishing," he said.

Earlier today, ISP iiNet welcomed the agreement.

"iiNet has always believed [the national broadband network] would be better served by having Telstra involved rather than not," iiNet chief Michael Malone said.

Other ISPs have also been contacted by iTnews for comment.


Telstra-NBN Co agreement no surety: ISPs
 
 
 
Top Stories
Don’t mention digital disruption to David Whiteing
Buzzwords don’t curry favour with CBA's new CIO - it’s all just innovation to him.
 
Content, cost & constant innovation: How Foxtel plans to take on Netflix
Nell Payne inhabits the “brave new world of blue strings and networking”. Just don't ask her to put a TV screen on your microwave.
 
Westpac fires starting pistol on core banking upgrade
St George readies itself for move to Celeriti.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Microsoft launches Office for Android preview
May 22, 2015
Microsoft has launched a preview of Office for Android smartphones. Pre-release versions of ...
Microsoft is working on an iOS email chat feature called Flow
May 22, 2015
Microsoft is working on a new chat app, but at the moment we know more about what we DON'T know, ...
Windows 10 free upgrade: Microsoft details who gets what
May 22, 2015
Microsoft was meant to be streamlining its OS with Windows 10, so why is upgrading so confusing? ...
Windows 10 has an edition to suit everyone's needs
May 15, 2015
Microsoft unveils a mind-melting six editions of Windows 10 ahead of its Winter 2015 launch. ...
Firefox 38 FINAL released, debuts new tab-based preferences
May 13, 2015
Mozilla has unveiled the latest version of Firefox 38.0 FINAL for desktop, with Firefox for ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Should Optus make a bid for iiNet?

   |   View results
Yes
  42%
 
No
  58%
TOTAL VOTES: 581

Vote