Economists, analysts dispute NBN study numbers

 

Were the authors too optimistic in their assumptions?

Economists and analysts are lining up to challenge the assumptions and calculations made in the NBN Implementation Study, prepared by McKinsey-KPMG after a $25 million commission from the Federal Government.

The NBN Implementation Study, which found that the National Broadband Network build could break even on its $43 billion cost, made a series of calculations and recommendations based on the assumption that half of the Australian population would seek NBN services, paying the same price as today but for faster connection speeds.

Bold assumptions

Ovum telecommunications analyst Nathan Burley took issue with some of the assumptions whilst presenting a top-line view of the mobile industry at the 4G Summit yesterday.

Burley said he was surprised that the Study "downplayed the wireless trend" present in the Australian market.

Whilst he acknowledges that mobile broadband isn't always a substitute for fixed services, it nonetheless can substitute - particularly for lower-speed ADSL users, he said. 

Wireless broadband is "more of a threat than the study suggests," he said.

Telstra has noted an accelerating trend towards "wireless-only homes" in its November and February forecasts, he said, which represents "both a substitute and a complement to fixed broadband."

Burley estimated that 10 to 15 percent of Australian households would substitute NBN fibre for wireless.

"The Implementation Study assumes high level of fixed broadband take-up," he said. "If people don't want broadband, or if they choose wireless broadband, you'd have to question that uptake. I think the assumptions on takeup were very optimistic."

Commentators on the Twisted Wire podcast were similarly dismissive - suggesting that the study was based on "heroic assumptions".

Bad economics

Economist Paul Kerin has also cast doubt on the Government's expectation of a profitable NBN Co, but for different reasons. He claims that the implementation study "got the numbers wrong".

In an article in The Australian last week, the Melbourne Business School fellow argued that the $25m McKinsey-KPMG implementation study used the wrong 'discount rate' in comparing future returns with the cost of funding NBN Co.

While the study claimed NBN Co would deliver returns exceeding the six percent government bond rate, Kerin argued that returns should exceed at least twelve percent to account for risk.

"Even if we accept that their forecast cash flows are reasonable - which I don't, they're far too optimistic - the number that is wrong is the six percent discount rate," he told iTnews today.

"Investors require higher expected returns to compensate for bearing risk. They would therefore discount future cash flows by a much higher discount rate, probably at least 12 percent, allowing for a conservative six percent premium above the bond rate."

"The business case does not stack up," he said.

Kerin blamed McKinsey-KPMG for choosing the wrong discount rate, "and therefore drawing the completely wrong conclusion about whether the business case stacks up."

He blamed the Government for failing to conduct a cost-benefit analysis from the outset -- despite lobbying from the Business Council of Australia and Opposition -- and concluded that taxpayers should demand a $25 million refund.

Kerin told iTnews that he regretted his decision to vote for the current Labor government, and believed there was "absolutely zero" chance of the Government conducting a cost-benefit analysis now.

"It would be political suicide now," he said. "A NBN was a pre-election promise and they will proceed come-what-may."

"They don't want any risk that a cost-benefit analysis would show that they made the wrong decision."

Would you choose a fibre NBN service over wireless or ADSL2+?


Economists, analysts dispute NBN study numbers
 
 
 
Top Stories
Frugality as a service: the Amazon story
Behind the scenes, Amazon Web Services is one lean machine.
 
Negotiating with the cloud email megavendors
[Blog post] Lessons from Woolworths’ mammoth migration.
 
Qld govt to move up to 149k staff onto Office 365
Australia's largest deployment, outside of the universities.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

The great data centre opportunity on Australia's doorstep
The great data centre opportunity on Australia's doorstep
Scott Noteboom, CEO of LitBit speaking at The Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit 2014 in the Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia. http://bit.ly/1qpxVfV Scott Noteboom is a data centre engineer who led builds for Apple and Yahoo in the earliest days of the cloud, and who now eyes Asia as the next big opportunity. Read more: http://www.itnews.com.au/News/372482,how-do-we-serve-three-billion-new-internet-users.aspx#ixzz2yNLmMG5C
Interview: Karl Maftoum, CIO, ACMA
Interview: Karl Maftoum, CIO, ACMA
To COTS or not to COTS? iTnews asks Karl Maftoum, CIO of the ACMA, at the CIO Strategy Summit.
Susan Sly: What is the Role of the CIO?
Susan Sly: What is the Role of the CIO?
AEMO chief information officer Susan Sly calls for more collaboration among Australia's technology leaders at the CIO Strategy Summit.
Meet the 2014 Finance CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Finance CIO of the Year
Credit Union Australia's David Gee awarded Finance CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards.
Meet the 2014 Retail CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Retail CIO of the Year
Damon Rees named Retail CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at Woolworths.
Robyn Elliott named the 2014 Utilities CIO of the Year
Robyn Elliott named the 2014 Utilities CIO of the Year
Acting Foxtel CIO David Marks accepts an iTnews Benchmark Award on behalf of Robyn Elliott.
Meet the 2014 Industrial CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Industrial CIO of the Year
Sanjay Mehta named Industrial CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at ConocoPhillips.
Meet the 2014 Healthcare CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Healthcare CIO of the Year
Greg Wells named Healthcare CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at NSW Health.
Meet the 2014 Education CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Education CIO of the Year
William Confalonieri named Healthcare CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at Deakin University.
Meet the 2014 Government CIO of the Year
Meet the 2014 Government CIO of the Year
David Johnson named Government CIO of the Year at the iTnews Benchmark Awards for his work at the Queensland Police Service.
Q and A: Coalition Broadband Policy
Q and A: Coalition Broadband Policy
Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott discuss the Coalition's broadband policy with the press.
AFP scalps hacker 'leader' inside Australia's IT ranks.
AFP scalps hacker 'leader' inside Australia's IT ranks.
The Australian Federal Police have arrested a Sydney-based IT security professional for hacking a government website.
NBN Petition Delivered To Turnbull's Office
NBN Petition Delivered To Turnbull's Office
UTS CIO: IT teams of the future
UTS CIO: IT teams of the future
UTS CIO Chrissy Burns talks data.
New UTS Building: the IT within
New UTS Building: the IT within
The IT behind tomorrow's universities.
iTnews' NBN Panel
iTnews' NBN Panel
Is your enterprise NBN-ready?
Introducing iTnews Labs
Introducing iTnews Labs
See a timelapse of the iTnews labs being unboxed, set up and switched on! iTnews will produce independent testing of the latest enterprise software to hit the market after installing a purpose-built test lab in Sydney. Watch the installation of two DL380p servers, two HP StoreVirtual 4330 storage arrays and two HP ProCurve 2920 switches.
The True Cost of BYOD
The True Cost of BYOD
iTnews' Brett Winterford gives attendees of the first 'Touch Tomorrow' event in Brisbane a brief look at his research into enterprise mobility. What are the use cases and how can they be quantified? What price should you expect to pay for securing mobile access to corporate applications? What's coming around the corner?
Ghost clouds
Ghost clouds
ACMA chair Chris Chapman says there is uncertainty over whether certain classes of cloud service providers are caught by regulations.
Was the Snowden leak inevitable?
Was the Snowden leak inevitable?
Privacy experts David Vaile (UNSW Cyberspace Law and Policy Centre) and Craig Scroggie (CEO, NextDC) claim they were not surprised by the Snowden leaks about the NSA's PRISM program.
Latest Comments
Polls
Which bank is most likely to suffer an RBS-style meltdown?





   |   View results
ANZ
  21%
 
Bankwest
  9%
 
CommBank
  11%
 
National Australia Bank
  17%
 
Suncorp
  24%
 
Westpac
  19%
TOTAL VOTES: 1429

Vote