Coalition still likes OPEL broadband template

Mar 12, 2010 1:24 PM
Tags: coalition | tony | smith | opposition | broadband | minister | nbn | policy | atug

Denies vague NBN policy adding to uncertainty.

Opposition Communications Minister Tony Smith was again forced to dodge questions on the Coalition’s NBN policy, promising a policy outline “in good time.”

Speaking after a “policy update” to the Australian Telecommunications User Group (ATUG) conference, Smith faced a number of questions on whether the Coalition would scale back or otherwise change the NBN rollout should it win power at the next election.

“I’m not going to commentate on what we may or may not do,” Smith said.

“I’ll make an announcement when we release our policy in good time.”

Smith had earlier indicated the Coalition was unhappy with the Government’s NBN approach. It remained to be seen what that would mean for the project if it were to land in the Coalition’s lap after the next election.

“We do want to see faster, better and more affordable broadband but it doesn’t mean we have to agree with the approach the Government has taken [and it doesn’t mean] taxpayers should be made to carry most of the risk,” Smith said.

He believed the OPEL project - which the Federal Government canned in favour of NBN - still represented “a reasonable template”.

“What the Government is looking at [with broadband is the equivalent of] looking at the national highway system, seeing a number of defects and saying ‘What we’re going to do is build an entirely new highway system and the public can deal with [the old one] as it is,” Smith said.

Smith told ATUG delegates that there appeared to be “no certainty” in the Federal Government’s eight-year NBN timeframe that faster broadband would actually be delivered as promised.

He denied the Coalition was adding to that uncertainty through its lack of policy guidance.

“I note the artist’s impression and architect’s drawings are impressive but when it comes to delivery it’s often chaotic,” Smith said.

“Even if NBN Co end up getting access to Telstra infrastructure and their ducts, there are still very many real hurdles and obstacles.

“We all know that system of ducts or pipes was built over many decades and that the layout obviously mirrored our urban expansion.”

He said that meant there was “no great universality” in their design or capacity. That meant fibre may be threaded through existing ducts (in addition to or in place of copper) or hung overhead.

He claimed Senator Conroy had “not been keen to talk about” at what level overhead wires would be hung with respect to other overhead cables - leading to some head-shaking amongst delegates and audible mutters of “that’s not true.”

The only policies outlined were in response to legislation being introduced to Parliament.

Smith re-iterated his party’s opposition to the break-up of Telstra but added another bill - prescribing amendments to the Do Not Call Register - to those which the Coalition would attempt to vote down.

“We will not support the Do Not Call Legislation in it’s current form when it comes before the House,” he said.

“Extending it to business-to-business calls would be the creation of another Conroy train wreck which is very much in the making.

“It would be very much in public interest terms if the Minister withdrew his bill.”


Compare our range of broadband providers to get a better deal today.

  • Email a Friend
  • Print Page
Coalition still likes OPEL broadband template
 
Comments

Be the first to comment on this article.
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
Comment:
Want to participate in the discussion?
Or log in now to comment
 
 
 
Top Stories
Oracle shuts down open source test servers
Playing nice with the open source community, Larry?
 
Google hosts election debate
Lundy, Fletcher and Ludlam face off on tech policies.
 
Telstra fined $18.5m for exchange access
Kept competitive DSLAM kit out.
 

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
"Now Julia, if only you would promise not to filter the internet in your next term of government ..."
by hsvandrew Jul 31, 2010 9:33 AM
 
"@Nate - my fears are that if we use a national consortium as an interface to international ..."
by heavenlyhaloes Jul 31, 2010 12:41 AM
 
"Did anybody notice that on Apple's website the iPhone is missing the AT&T logo on the top bar? ..."
by brownenicola Jul 30, 2010 10:18 PM
 
"@digger11 - when will you learn just to remain quiet when you don't have all the facts or a ..."
by Bazwalt Jul 30, 2010 7:13 PM
 
"Wakie is right, Digger11 is either an exceptional forum troll or a massive moron. For those who ..."
by Bazwalt Jul 30, 2010 6:51 PM
Polls
Did Google breach the Telecommunications Interception or Privacy Acts during its WiFi wardrive?

   |   View results
Yes. There is no excuse for collecting this data.
  28%
 
No. If your wireless network is unsecured, you have no right to complain
  72%
TOTAL VOTES: 1873

Vote