Telstra and the Government ponder iiNet victory

 

ISPs applaud the judge's clarity, Conroy's response muted.

View larger image
iiNet CEO Michael Malone arrives at court with his entourage at exactly 9:30am.
View larger image
The Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft (AFACT), representing the film industry, was ...
View larger image
iiNet CEO Michael Malone said the case proved that AFACT's approach had "wasted a year" and not ...

See all pictures here »

Telstra and the Internet Industry Association have welcomed the "legal clarity" the Federal Court provided internet providers by ruling in favour of iiNet in a case levelled by the film industry.

As reported live from the court by iTnews.com.au, Justice Dennis Cowdroy found Australia's No.3 ISP iiNet did not authorise copyright infringement on its network. He ordered the Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft representing film studios ordered to pay iiNet's costs, about $4 million.

"We welcome the legal clarity today's judgement provides regarding the role of ISPs," said a spokesman for Telstra, Australia's largest ISP.

"As one of the major content publishers in Australia we do not condone piracy and we encourage the lawful use of our services. Allegations of wrongdoing should be dealt with in accordance with due legal process, with which we will always cooperate fully."

Internet Industry Association chief executive officer IPeter Coroneossaid it was a "very important decision for the internet industry in Australia" and one that will "no doubt be watched globally".

"There is an international campaign afoot to try and force ISPs to accept responsibility for the acts of their customers," he said. "Our position has always been to argue for balance - the balance between legitimate rights of content owners on the one hand and the legitimate rights of those that make the internet possible as intermediaries."

Coroneos said the association will continue to explore "new commercial models for consumers to be given access to affordable, accessible and legal content" with content owners.

But the response from Federal Communications Minister Senator Stephen Conroy was far less jubilant.

The Minister had vowed to tackle illegal file sharing, labelling iiNet's defence as "stunning", will help him inform policy.

Today the Minister was only prepared to release a brief statement through a spokesman.

"The Government will examine the Federal Court's decision in the AFACT/iiNet case and will consider what the implications for the industry are."


"Yes, I think you've got it, FLashy. Except he will have the power to secretly remove a lot more than just newspapers. All AFACT nominated content, for instance? And we'll never know, because ..."
By anonymous
 
 
 
Comments: 4
anonymous
Feb 4, 2010 5:53 PM

Maybe Conroy has been thinking (always a painful process) about he can align his secret government filter with the interests of the content corporations. Perhaps there will be more along these lines?

Lamby
Feb 5, 2010 12:10 AM
Again, Conroy showing he does not 'get' the Internet.

Why does Australia seem to have a Luddite for our communications minister?
FLashy
Feb 5, 2010 2:55 PM
Horror idea just came to me.
Imagine if you could, the Government becomes an ISP, offering cheap high speed connection via it's own NBN optic fibre network.
Silently in the background the "FILTER" does it's bidding from it's dark lord and master.
Shudder...... a Glimpse of Mr Conroy as the Dark Lord directing his minions to remove anti government sites like newspapers from the Worldwide net.
anonymous
Feb 5, 2010 6:01 PM

Yes, I think you've got it, FLashy. Except he will have the power to secretly remove a lot more than just newspapers. All AFACT nominated content, for instance?

And we'll never know, because it's all a secret.

Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
 
Top Stories
Windows 8: Under the hood
Part One of iTnews' enterprise guide to Windows 8.
 
iTnews on tour: The Executive Summit Series
Join us in Sydney and Melbourne to meet Australia's tech leaders.
 
Meet Westpac's new technology leaders
Engineering realigned under CTO.
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Was your 2012 IT budget...




   |   View results
Cut by less than ten percent?
  15%
 
Cut by more than ten percent?
  34%
 
Flat
  27%
 
Increased by less than ten percent?
  7%
 
Increased by more than ten percent?
  16%
TOTAL VOTES: 409

Vote
Will you still use DropBox and other cloud storage in the wake of the Megauploads saga?

   |   View results
Yes
  65%
 
No
  35%
TOTAL VOTES: 303

Vote