Day 20: iiNet refuses to play police for film industry

 

iiNet continues closing statements.

ISP iiNet should not have to accept the film industry’s “outsourcing” of rights management or deal with the fallout from passing on infringement notices, the Federal Court heard today.

Continuing his closing statements, iiNet’s lead barrister Richard Cobden argued against what the film industry has portrayed as “reasonable steps” for dealing with copyright infringement, claiming they place an “unreasonable burden” on the ISP.

“We will not take on the rights holders’ outsourcing of their rights enforcement,” Cobden said.

“The rights holders and studios say this [allegedly infringing] activity is incredibly damaging, [that they] are suffering from the effects of online piracy. Presumably they still make some money [from films] but what they say to ISPs is ‘you fix it up for us, but we’re not going to pay a cent’.”

Cobden characterised that response as a “big ask” of iiNet or any ISP.

He said that passing on notices of alleged copyright infringement could burden ISPs with higher levels of “complaints and disputes”.

“If a customer wishes to dispute what they’ve been accused of [in the notice] then the debate would be between AFACT and the customer,” Cobden stated.

“At the moment, the proposal from AFACT is effectively that iiNet pass on this information. The customer can then say; ‘That’s not right. What’s your basis [for the accusation]?’

Cobden told the court that iiNet was not in a position to respond to these types of requests because the “basis” was information not contained in its IT systems.

“It’s nothing like dealing with our own business issues, where a customer might ask ‘what’s the basis’ and we can tell them ‘our records show you haven’t paid your bill’,” Cobden stated.

“There’s no reason we should have the burden of dealing with complaints and disputes [involving AFACT notices] or escalations to the TIO.”

Cobden also said these steps were unreasonable because not every ISP received notifications from AFACT.

“An ISP only becomes liable if AFACT decides to make it liable - until AFACT decides to target it with notifications,” he said.

“It goes to reasonableness - whether it’s reasonable to impose on iiNet that burden.”

Cobden said iiNet chief Michael Malone’s suggestion of the need for a change to the Copyright Act, the introduction of another “legislative instrument” or the formulation of an industry code to deal with copyright infringement was “sensible” - but not “a demonstration of iiNet’s refusal to accept copyright rules.”

Cobden was also highly critical of the alleged “reluctance” of copyright owners to pursue any of the sample of 20 iiNet account holders surfaced in discovery for the purposes of matching against the film industry’s evidence of alleged infringements.

He argued that iiNet’s alleged failure to terminate any of those 20 accounts did not make it “even more culpable” in the case.

“The real question is why the applicants haven’t done a single thing about it or all the other infringements they say occurred in relation to their copyright subject matter,” Cobden put to the court.

The case continues. You can follow the case in-full here. For a background on the case, click here.


Day 20: iiNet refuses to play police for film industry
 
 
 
Top Stories
Earning the right to innovate
Breaking down the barriers to innovation is a long, but rewarding process, says Bank of Queensland Group CIO, Julie Bale.
 
A call for timely reporting
[Blog post] Businesses need incentives to keep customer data secure.
 
Doubts cast on Queensland's ICT Dashboard
Opposition, former Govt CIO say it can't be trusted.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Have customers that won't pay debts?
Jul 10, 2014
The ACCC and ASIC have updated their advice when it comes to collecting debts.
Carpet cleaner faces court over online testimonials
Jul 4, 2014
The ACCC has initiated proceedings against A Whistle (1979) Pty Ltd, the franchisor of Electrodry...
You can now get 15GB of free online storage using Microsoft OneDrive
Jun 25, 2014
Cloud storage has reached both the capacity and price where it's a viable alternative to local ...
Another clever trick you can perform with Xero
Jun 25, 2014
Here is another way to reach out to particular subsets of your customers using Xero.
Have a phone, tablet and laptop?
Jun 20, 2014
This new Telstra pre-paid 4G mobile hotspot might be useful if you regularly need to use fast ...
Latest Comments
Polls
What is delaying adoption of public cloud in your organisation?







   |   View results
Lock-in concerns
  26%
 
Application integration concerns
  3%
 
Security and compliance concerns
  29%
 
Unreliable network infrastructure
  9%
 
Data sovereignty concerns
  23%
 
Lack of stakeholder support
  3%
 
Protecting on-premise IT jobs
  5%
 
Difficulty transitioning CapEx budget into OpEx
  3%
TOTAL VOTES: 827

Vote