Quigley and Conroy at odds over NBN pricing

 

Quigley bristles at the idea of subsidising regional access.

National Broadband Network Company CEO Mike Quigley has thrown cold water on a suggestion made by Senator Stephen Conroy that NBN Co should subsidise internet users in regional Australia.

According to an article in The Northern Leader, Senator Conroy said the NBN would "unashamedly and explicitly" offer "a cross-subsidy to deliver equivalent services to all Australians."

"My ambition is that there will be the same wholesale price for every household for the same speed across satellite, wireless and fibre-to-the-node," Conroy said. "This is about bringing every Australian up to speed, so to speak, after years of Australian telecommunications being far slower and more expensive than most of the rest of the world."

Liberal senator Mary Jo Fisher quoted these comments to NBN CEO Mike Quigley at a Senate Hearing into the NBN yesterday.

Mary Jo Fisher said her reading of Conroy's comments was that "NBN Co is going to have to provide ... wholesale customers with cross-subsidies".

But Quigley said this would not be the case.

"We won't be setting pricing policies in the company on the basis of quotes," Quigley said. "We'll be having discussion with the shareholders around those sorts of issues, as you would expect us to do. These are very important decisions."

Quigley agreed there were still question marks as to how to cross-subsidise rural customers so that they could be offered similar pricing to those in cities.

"This is exactly the issue that's the balancing act that we need to address if we are going to serve those rural and remote communities that are not so attractive commercially to serve," he said.

A spokesman for Senator Conroy told the Australian Financial Review last night that Senator Conroy stood by what he said.

"The national broadband network will offer uniform wholesale prices for the fibre network and, as was described by Senator Conroy at the broadband forum in Tamworth, there is an ambition to have a single price for the same speed across satellite, wireless, and fibre," the spokesman said.

"Final arrangements for national broadband network pricing will be determined as part of the implementation study."


Quigley and Conroy at odds over NBN pricing
"Here we go again... lol "Mary Jo Fisher said her reading of Conroy's comments was that "NBN Co is going to have to provide ... wholesale customers with cross-subsidies"." Operative words "her ..."
By Maxxi
 
 
 
Comments: 3
BigG
Oct 2, 2009 4:30 PM
There are some real issues with pricing a service like the NBN. The first thing that comes to mind is that existing telco's (not only Telstra!) are not about to give up their existing profitable customer connections in areas such as the CBD, big data centres and high density buildings to the NBN. This is where a lot of traffic gets routed. So will the NBN have to pay for access to these networks - you bet. The NBN will be marginalised to the less profitable areas from day one, suburbs, regional and remote areas.

And no telco is going to pay one dollar more for access to an NBN customer than they could do it for themselves. There are many other issues such as the pricing and supply of international links, interconnection points, multiple redundant access for critical sites, pricing for cached services - let alone the simple technical issues of getting the service connected and maintained.

I really don't think anyone has spent enough time thinking this one through.
anonymous
Oct 2, 2009 6:16 PM
Yes, of course there are (a lot of) issues in implementing a national network, but they can all be dealt with if we apply some common sense - and discard some of the talking-our-book self interest from representatives of the neo-monopolist fixed-line incumbent.

Any project as big as NBN has the possibility of getting stuffed up by a bazoomny collection of vested interests. It also has the potential to move Australian communications ahead by a full (people) generation, so we need to keep focussed on the national interest rather than the corporate vestment.
Maxxi
Oct 2, 2009 7:14 PM
Here we go again... lol

"Mary Jo Fisher said her reading of Conroy's comments was that "NBN Co is going to have to provide ... wholesale customers with cross-subsidies"."

Operative words "her reading..."

Always the same old story, "her reading" / "his reading", her version / his version / their slant / whatever you want to make out of the original statement, and now IT News reports that Quigley and Conroy are at odds... lol

Well "my reading" of Turnbull's comments this week are that Mary Jo Fisher eats ox brains for breakfast, drives a bicycle backwards to work and has a strong urge to stuff diet pills down Hockey's throat by the handful every time she sees him...

I listened to Quigley on that broadcast, and he was spending a lot of time clarifying the false interpretations that the senators were tabling.

Now either some of those senators were simply playing stupid and ignorant of some pretty public information, or are indeed stupid and ignorant of some pretty public information...

Which is a worry if they are a committee asking questions and making recommendations about the NBN.

Mostly some of them were trying to get Quigley to say something that they could nail Conroy with...

We call that "baiting", and is pretty ordinary. Quigley was couple of levels of quality above several of those, especially that McDonald fellow, who was just a rude and continually interrupting, baiting tool. Condenscending is the word.

Pretending he knew nothing, asked some idiot leading questions, then all of a sudden knew loads and tried to trip up Quigley...

That we call lack of consideration and basic courtesy...
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
 
Top Stories
The New Zealand telco problem
Opinion: Could Telstra save Kiwi telcos?
 
IT price probe to 'name and shame' gougers
Industry ducking the issue, committee claims.
 
Revealed: 2012 e-government award winners
Government highlights projects, professionals of the year.
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Should the Government enact new legislation to protect copyright holders in the digital age?

   |   View results
Yes
  19%
 
No
  81%
TOTAL VOTES: 480

Vote