Woman cops $2.4 million fine for file sharing

 

Appeal likely over "grossly excessive" damages.

The Recording Industry Association of America has been awarded a US$1.92 million (AU$2.4 million) decision against a woman accused of sharing music online.

A jury ruled that Jammie Thomas-Rasset violated record label copyrights by downloading 24 songs from file-sharing service Kazaa.

The jury awarded the labels statutory damages of US$80,000 per song, totalling some $1.92 million.

The case was first made news in 2007 when a jury had originally ordered Thomas-Rasset to pay a fine of US$224,000.

The decision was later thrown out due to the judges mis-direction of the jury and a re-trial was ordered.

The case has been held up as a landmark battle between the RIAA and those accused of downloading music. Most of the accused have settled out of court and few cases have actually gone to trial.

However, the case is likely far from being officially decided according to experts.

Electronic Frontier Foundation senior attorney Fred von Lohmann noted that the case would likely be appealed.

"Given the size of the statutory damages award, Ms. Thomas-Rasset's legal team will likely be seriously considering a constitutional challenge to the verdict," wrote von Lohmann.

Von Lohmann noted previous cases in which similarly large damages were overturned by higher courts as 'grossly excessive' along with Supreme Court rulings which question the authority of juries to award damages in similar cases.

Copyright ©v3.co.uk


 
 
 
 
 
Top Stories
iTnews on tour: The Executive Summit Series
Join us in Sydney and Melbourne to meet Australia's tech leaders.
 
NBN Co braces for secrecy probe
Opinion: Is commercial sensitivity a catch-all?
 
Exclusive: NBN Co withholds fibre upgrade price
Fears trial details could breach contractor confidentiality.
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Was your 2012 IT budget...




   |   View results
Cut by less than ten percent?
  17%
 
Cut by more than ten percent?
  34%
 
Flat
  26%
 
Increased by less than ten percent?
  7%
 
Increased by more than ten percent?
  15%
TOTAL VOTES: 350

Vote
Will you still use DropBox and other cloud storage in the wake of the Megauploads saga?

   |   View results
Yes
  63%
 
No
  37%
TOTAL VOTES: 230

Vote