iTnews
  • Home
  • News
  • Digital Nation
  • Governance
Digital Nation

Carbon offset myths lead to improper actions and decisions, says Bain & Co

By Tom Duvall
Nov 18 2021 7:00AM

Four common misconceptions.

Ambitious decarbonisation and net-zero goals are being set by companies globally, however the early stages of carbon-offset markets has led to confusion and greenwashing accusations for many.

Carbon offset myths lead to improper actions and decisions, says Bain & Co

An article by Bain and Co. titled “Four Myths about Carbon Offsets”, by Torsten Lichtenau, Dale Hardcastle, Allister Furey, and Henning Huenteler, details common misconceptions and their implications for leaders going forward.

1. Offsets are greenwashing
Carbon offsets are not greenwashing as long as they represent additional decarbonisation to balance a company’s carbon emissions.

When offsets are an aspect of a broader, science-based decarbonisation strategy, they serve as a significant contribution to a company’s efforts to reach net zero.

“While validation of offset projects needs to improve, these purchases aren’t greenwashing if they represent real carbon capture and form a complementary lever for companies to reach net zero, beyond the decarbonisation of their own operations and value chains,” say the authors.

2. Carbon offsets are unique and too complex to behave like other markets
The carbon-offset markets are young and developing, however the authors say that they are likely to evolve into mature trading systems, in line with other financial and commodity markets.

Constantly monitoring critical signposts of change while remaining flexible and diligent on frequent strategic corrections is encouraged by Bain and Co. while demand for these markets will drive more rigid structures.

3. Offset projects that remove carbon are always better than those that simply conserve existing resources or avoid new emissions.

While markets are still standardising, and every carbon project is different, diligent analysis of risks and benefits of each project is necessary.

“Stricter and more specific project standards and governance will help improve the integrity of offsets. But in a maturing market environment with increasing levels of standardisation, buyers should also take a proactive approach to assess the quality of potential investments,” the authors say.

4. Capital inflows will help scale markets quickly
The supply of offsets is tightening, according to Bain and Co., meaning that there will be a shift from a buyers’ market into a sellers’ market.

Due to increasingly constrained markets, companies should consider a range of participation options to secure supply in increasingly constrained markets.

Relying solely on the market to solve supply crunches will leave many companies at risk of higher prices and low inventory, meaning that action should be taken as soon as possible.

As companies form decarbonisation strategies, a deep understanding of the offsets market must be developed, and innovative solutions must be sought.

“To make informed decisions, companies need data and analysis that goes beyond the spotty data that’s publicly available, so they can form a more comprehensive picture of carbon-offset quality and market forces,” the article says.

“With that data, companies can make informed choices about offsets, including the associated risks, and how to mitigate them. Finally, most companies will integrate offsets into their broader decarbonization and ESG strategies, which may include building up new capabilities for securing and developing offset projects.”

Got a news tip for our journalists? Share it with us anonymously here.
Digital Nation

You just read a Digital Nation story.

There are many others like it. Subscribe to our new weekly Digital Nation e-newsletter for more HR, finance, marketing, risk and emerging technology news and discussions.

SUBSCRIBE
© Digital Nation
Tags:
baincarboncarbon offsetsgovernancesustainability

Related Articles

  • The Northern Beaches Women's Shelter hones focus on tech-enabled abuse The Northern Beaches Women's Shelter hones focus on tech-enabled abuse
  • Lawyers face sanctions for citing fake cases with AI Lawyers face sanctions for citing fake cases with AI
  • King & Wood Mallesons Australia to give Gen AI tool to 1200 lawyers King & Wood Mallesons Australia to give Gen AI tool to 1200 lawyers
  • Transport for NSW expands SAP Ariba usage Transport for NSW expands SAP Ariba usage

Partner Content

Ransomware targets Australian SME false sense of security
Partner Content Ransomware targets Australian SME false sense of security
ElasticON Sydney 2025: Deriving value from your data with Search AI
Partner Content ElasticON Sydney 2025: Deriving value from your data with Search AI
Elastic's Open Source Strategy Drives Innovation and Expansion
Partner Content Elastic's Open Source Strategy Drives Innovation and Expansion
AI Supercharged: How Search is Powering the Future
Partner Content AI Supercharged: How Search is Powering the Future

Sponsored Whitepapers

Leverage Technologies: Industry-Tailored ERP Implementation for Growth and Compliance
Leverage Technologies: Industry-Tailored ERP Implementation for Growth and Compliance
Service Over Signatures: The Truth About No Lock-In IT
Service Over Signatures: The Truth About No Lock-In IT
Wasabi Reveals Hidden Costs and Cloud Storage Shifts in ANZ for 2025
Wasabi Reveals Hidden Costs and Cloud Storage Shifts in ANZ for 2025
Datacom + Microsoft Azure: Turn Ideas Into Impact in Just 4 Weeks
Datacom + Microsoft Azure: Turn Ideas Into Impact in Just 4 Weeks
Protect APIs. Protect Your Business.
Protect APIs. Protect Your Business.

Events

  • Tech in Gov 2025 Tech in Gov 2025
  • Forrester's Technology & Innovation Summit APAC 2025 Forrester's Technology & Innovation Summit APAC 2025
  • Security Exhibition & Conference 2025 Security Exhibition & Conference 2025
  • Integrate Expo 2025 Integrate Expo 2025
  • Digital As Usual Cybersecurity Roadshow: Brisbane edition Digital As Usual Cybersecurity Roadshow: Brisbane edition
Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Whatsapp Email A Friend

Most Read Articles

King & Wood Mallesons Australia to give Gen AI tool to 1200 lawyers

King & Wood Mallesons Australia to give Gen AI tool to 1200 lawyers

ANZ continues work on data "one-stop-shop" for its Risk function

ANZ continues work on data "one-stop-shop" for its Risk function

The University of Sydney revamps its contract management

The University of Sydney revamps its contract management

COVER STORY: Technology alone can't beat cybercrime. Attack the economic triggers say CISOs

COVER STORY: Technology alone can't beat cybercrime. Attack the economic triggers say CISOs

techpartner.news logo
Dave Stevens on Brennan's evolution and the need for Aussie tech unity
Dave Stevens on Brennan's evolution and the need for Aussie tech unity
Sydney's ITKnocks on contact centre AI and the slow death of the IVR
Sydney's ITKnocks on contact centre AI and the slow death of the IVR
"It's an exciting time to be part of the health and aged care sector"
"It's an exciting time to be part of the health and aged care sector"
Insicon founder Matt Miller on the coming 'tsunami' of compliance and educating boards about cyber security
Insicon founder Matt Miller on the coming 'tsunami' of compliance and educating boards about cyber security
Orro claims Australia first with managed digital asset discovery service
Orro claims Australia first with managed digital asset discovery service
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.