US sale ban on Samsung Galaxy 10.1 upheld

 

But may be lifted between injunctions.

A US judge has refused Samsung's request to lift an injunction on the sale of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet in the country.

In a further setback for the company's ongoing patent war with Apple, the decision upholds a ban on the tablet first implemented in June.

Even so, intellectual property analyst Florian Mueller argued the request had only succeded to a limited extent, and Samsung may be allowed to sell the tablet again for a few months before a permanent injunction is taken out against by Apple.

According to Mueller, district court judge Lucy Koh — who has overseen much of the legal battle between the competing smartphone makers in the US — denied Samsung's motion for immediate dissolution of the preliminary injunction on purely procedural grounds.

Judge Koh did not hold that the August verdict, in which a jury ruled the Galaxy 10.1 Tablet did not infringe on Apple's design, meant the temporary injunction had been automatically dissolved.

Mueller said the continuing legal wrangle between the two electronics giants could see the temporary injunction being lifted, possibly in September or October, only to be reinstated after a hearing on December 6 this year.

"The court's chosen path comes with a significant risk of an on-again, off-again sales ban, which might be justified but would really be odd," he said.

Apple has scored several substantial legal victories against Samsung in US courts. Last Friday, a judge at the International Trade Commission ruled that Apple did not violate four patents held by Samsung when the US company made its iPod Touch, iPhone and iPad devices.

In August this year, Apple was awarded $US1.05 billion ($A994 million) in damages against Samsung, after a jury decided the Korean company had copied important features of the iPhone.

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


US sale ban on Samsung Galaxy 10.1 upheld
 
 
 
Top Stories
Brandis hits telcos with new security reforms
Civil penalties for those who don't comply.
 
When does an insurance company turn into a software vendor?
The lines are blurring for ASX-listed Cover-More Group.
 
APIs: rivets for the composable enterprise
Expanding a savvy CIO's toolbox.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
New Microsoft Office apps for Android phones
Jun 26, 2015
Microsoft's latest Office apps for Android now work on phones as well as tablets, further ...
Windows 10 UK price revealed, but don't believe everything you hear
Jun 26, 2015
Windows 10 £99 price tag for users in the UK (who presumably don't already have Win 7 Pro ...
Now Xero notifies iOS users of new transactions
Jun 24, 2015
The latest version of Xero's iPhone app includes notifications when new transactions arrive from ...
Your Essential Cloud Toolbox
Jun 22, 2015
When BIT interviewed Receipt Bank country manager Sophie Hossack, we asked for her thoughts on ...
Toshiba laptops to get “Cortana button” ahead of Windows 10 launch
Jun 19, 2015
Toshiba introduces 12 new laptops, all aimed at getting the most out of Microsoft's digital ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Is site blocking effective in stopping piracy?


   |   View results
Yes
  2%
 
No
  86%
 
Somewhat
  12%
TOTAL VOTES: 465

Vote