US commission bans some HTC phones


Updated: Apple gains narrow victory in ITC ruling.

HTC will be banned from importing new versions of some of its smartphones into the US from April next year after a long-awaited ruling by the country's trade commission found the Taiwanese manufacturer infringed one of Apple's patents.

The formal import ban, to begin on April 19, will prevent HTC from selling Android phones implementing feature that infringe on Apple's "data tapping" patent.

According to patent blogger Florian Mueller, the patent covers a smartphone's ability to automatically recognise phone numbers and other usable data in text and highlight them as links which can execute on that data in other applications.

"The import ban won't relate to HTC Android products that don't implement that feature, or that implement it in ways not covered by those patent claims," Mueller said following the ruling.

It was one of four patents asserted by Apple in a US court in July, before the matter was referred to the US International Trade Commission (ITC) for review. The commission postponed its ruling twice this month.

While finding HTC had violated two claims asserted under the data tapping patent, the commission reversed the US court's July finding that HTC had also violated other Apple patent claims.

According to the ITC's ruling [pdf] released this morning, HTC will be able to continue importing refurbished models of the infringing smartphones until the end of 2013 to cover any replacements required for those who had already purchased the phone.

It enforced the ban from April next year to "provide a transition period for US carriers".

Mueller said the ITC's judgment was a narrow victory for Apple but based on a patent of "medium value".

"[Apple] now has one patent that it can also assert against other Android device makers unless the data tapping feature can be implemented in non-infringing ways, in which case there wouldn't even be a point in suing other Android device makers over it," he said.

"If Google can implement this popular feature, which users of modern-day smartphones really expect, without infringing on the two patent claims found infringed, this import ban won't have any effect whatsoever."

Forbes quoted a HTC spokesman as saying the company would "completely remove" the infringing feature from its phones to circumvent the ruling.

The ITC is simultaneously reviewing another decision between HTC and Apple this month.

Copyright © . All rights reserved.

US commission bans some HTC phones
Top Stories
Myer CIO named retailer's new chief executive
Richard Umbers to lead data-driven retail strategy.
Empty terminals and mountains of data
Qantas CIO Luc Hennekens says no-one is safe from digital disruption.
BoQ takes $10m hit on Salesforce CRM
Regulatory hurdles end cloud pilot.
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
Latest Comments
Who do you trust most to protect your private data?

   |   View results
Your bank
Your insurance company
A technology company (Google, Facebook et al)
Your telco, ISP or utility
A retailer (Coles, Woolworths et al)
A Federal Government agency (ATO, Centrelink etc)
An Australian law enforcement agency (AFP, ASIO et al)
A State Government agency (Health dept, etc)

Do you support the abolition of the Office of the Information Commissioner?

   |   View results
I support shutting down the OAIC.
I DON'T support shutting the OAIC.