Court blocks sales of Samsung's Galaxy Tab

 

Updated: Apple wins interim injunction against Galaxy Tab 10.1.

The Federal Court of Australia has granted an interim injunction against the sale of Samsung's Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet.

The judgment, handed down at midday on Thursday by Justice Annabelle Bennett, prevented Samsung from selling the tablet in Australia until a final hearing of Apple's patent claims.

Reasons for the judgment were ruled to be confidential until a directions hearing scheduled for Friday of this week.

Apple alleged Samsung had infringed up to 13 patents in Australia in attempting to launch the Galaxy Tab 10.1 locally but had focused on five of these to gain a temporary injunction.

During the course of hearings, Apple's counsel removed one of these patent claims while Samsung undertook to remove features relating to two further patents from the Australian version of the tablet.

It left two remaining patents relied on by Apple to push its case, comprising a heuristics patent (2007286532), which corrected a user's intended finger gestures on the touch screen, and the manufacturing techniques behind the iPad and iPad 2's touch screen (2005246219).

The judgment comes as the first major step in an ongoing patent battle between the South Korean manufacturer and Apple initially launched in Australia in late July.

It is one of several cases before courts in countries including the US, South Korea, Japan, Germany and the Netherlands.

Samsung has filed its own claims against Apple claiming infringements against its wireless communication patents in Australia and has more recently attempted to block the sale of the new iPhone 4S in Italy and France.

A date for final hearings has not been set, with Samsung's counsel unwilling to meet in November this year, as suggested by Apple.

Apple refused to comment on the ruling.

A Samsung spokesman said the company was "disappointed" with the result.

"Samsung will be seeking legal advice on its options," the spokesman said.

"Samsung will continue its legal proceeding against Apple‘s claim in order to ensure our innovative products remain available to consumers.

"We will continue to legally assert our intellectual property rights against those who violate Samsung’s patents and free ride on our technology."

First for Australia

Mark Summerfield, an intellectual property specialist with patent firm Watermark, said the decision is likely the first of its kind in Australia for a consumer technology product.

"To work on just the basis of a preliminary hearing and decide to keep a product off the market, particularly a competitive product in a competitive market, is not just harmful to the manufacturer of that product if you get it wrong, it’s harmful to the consumer," he said.

The Federal Court's changing approach to interim injunctions in recent years is a result of pharmaceutical patent trials, which had also formed the basis of Apple's argument Samsung had infringed its products with "eyes wide open".

Beginning of the end?

The injunction could spell the end for the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in Australia, after Samsung's lawyers claimed that any further delays would effectively kill any chance the device had of gaining traction in Australia ahead of Christmas.

Samsung has already delayed the tablet three times over the course of the past three months in order to allow the interlocutory hearings to continue.

A full patent trial, likely to begin next year, could take a further 12 months prior to a final decision, according to Summerfield.

"They’re going to argue there’s no way you can compensate us because not only have we lost sales for that period we have lost future sales because it will simply not be viable to bring that to market," he said.

"Samsung will simply have moved on, they’ll have another product they have brought to market in the meantime and yes it will be the end of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in any Australian variance."

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


Court blocks sales of Samsung's Galaxy Tab
 
 
 
Top Stories
Photos: iTnews Benchmark Awards countdown begins
Just a few days left until entries close for 2014.
 
Australian Govt to rethink cyber security strategy
Six-year old policy to be refreshed.
 
The failure of the antivirus industry
[Blog post] Insights from AVAR 2014.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
More 4G from Optus in Darwin
Nov 21, 2014
Click to see where Optus has expanded coverage to the suburbs near Darwin.
Optus steps up regional 4G coverage
Nov 20, 2014
Once 700Mhz services are working, Optus claims regional users will have a "faster and more ...
This Huawei 4G phone costs $99
Nov 12, 2014
The $99 Huawei Ascend Y550, available through Vodafone, enters the budget market as one of the ...
4G smartphones: Microsoft's Lumia 830
Nov 7, 2014
Microsoft has announced its flagship Windows Phone, the Nokia Lumia 830 4G, will be available in ...
Do you direct debit customers? Read this
Oct 10, 2014
Authorities have been targeting direct debit practices with iiNet and Dodo receiving formal ...
Latest Comments
Polls
Who do you trust most to protect your private data?







   |   View results
Your bank
  39%
 
Your insurance company
  3%
 
A technology company (Google, Facebook et al)
  8%
 
Your telco, ISP or utility
  7%
 
A retailer (Coles, Woolworths et al)
  2%
 
A Federal Government agency (ATO, Centrelink etc)
  20%
 
An Australian law enforcement agency (AFP, ASIO et al)
  15%
 
A State Government agency (Health dept, etc)
  5%
TOTAL VOTES: 1017

Vote