Growing pains: Amazon EC2 suffers huge outage

 
Page 1 of 2 | Single page

Described as the "worst outage in cloud computing history".

A large-scale outage affecting Amazon Web Services' Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2) over the Easter break has highlighted one of the many risks associated with running thousands of applications from large clusters of virtualised servers.

The outage - which began Thursday last week and still impacted a number of Amazon customers as late as Tuesday - took out popular social networking services Foursquare, FormSpring, Heroku, HootSuite, Quora and Reddit.

It also impacted many IT service providers that use Amazon as part of their total solution to end users, such as cloud management software vendor Right Scale.

The outage began Thursday at 6pm (Sydney time), when customers hosting applications at Amazon's cloud compute service (EC2) based at the US-EAST-1 data centre (in Virginia) began experiencing connectivity, latency and error rates.

On any normal day Amazon’s EBS - a giant storage area network - dynamically distributes small volumes of storage capacity to thousands of the physical servers hosting Amazon EC2 virtual server instances and to applications using Amazon’s Relational Database Service (RDS).

According to Amazon's status updates, a mysterious network event caused software monitoring of the EC2 network to incorrectly calculate that there was insufficient redundancy available to meet the needs of these server and database instances.

The software automatically attempted to move resources around the network to adjust – in effect a mass re-mirroring of storage that flooded the network with traffic.

In the chaos that ensued, Amazon ran out of capacity in its US-EAST-1 Availability Zone – with services failing faster than Amazon engineers could re-provision them.

Six hours after the unexplained network event, Amazon's technicians reported to customers that EBS-backed instances in the US-EAST-1 region were "failing at a high rate."

"Effectively, [Amazon's high availability software] launched a Denial-of-Service attack on their own infrastructure," explained Matt Moor, technical architect at a Sydney-based Amazon customer Bulletproof Networks, which fortunately relies primarily on providing services from its own infrastructure in Australia.

The outage initially affected multiple Amazon ‘availability zones’ (data centres) but by Friday morning, the company reported that most server instances across its compute cloud were again operational - with the exception of any applications hosted in the US-EAST-1 Availability Zone.

Customers with applications hosted in this zone suffered outages well into the weekend as Amazon engineers struggled to bring the large volume of services back online.

"The work we're doing to enable customers to be able to launch EBS backed instances and create, delete, attach and detach EBS volumes in the affected Availability Zone is taking considerably more time than we anticipated," Amazon's engineers reported on the company's status page.

Instances had to be re-provisioned slowly, the company reported, "in order to moderate the load on the control plane and prevent it from becoming overloaded and affecting other functions."

By Monday, Amazon reported that most instances were operational, advising those customers still experiencing issues to "stop and restart your instance in order to restore connectivity."

How did customers rate Amazon's response to the outage? Read on...

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


Growing pains: Amazon EC2 suffers huge outage
"Too many nuffies pushing the "cloud world" as the new way of outsourcing. When you move to the cloud you put your systems in the hands of someone else - beware. Maintain backups and your own ..."
By DJ
 
 
 
Comments: 3
BaysNet
Apr 27, 2011 1:19 PM
The Take outy here is to look for the interoperability and portability features of your cloud provider so YOU can take back control of your apps and data when and how you want. Elastic EC2 may be but if you stretch it too far it does break!
Lloyd
Apr 27, 2011 5:08 PM
I followed this 80+ hour sorry saga over Easter (e.g. via the AWS Service Health Dashboard), and also the responses of AMZN clients such as dotcloud.com. I know what it's like to have your server down and sympatise with the clients and the guys at AMZN trying to understand and fix the problem.

Before we even know what the cause is, we have people looking at SLA agreements (e.g. Lydia Leong at Gartner, who pointed out that the EC2 guarantee does not apply to component system (e.g. EBS and RDS) failure).

And then, to put an Australian perspective on this I looked at the reassuring advice in the DSD "Cloud Computing Considerations" (page 6), which suggest clients ensure that "The Service Level Agreement (SLA) GUARANTEES adequate system availability". Uh .. huh ...

The responses of clients were frustration and acceptance of the realisation of a worst scenario risk. Bottom line is to recognise that the whole idea of the internet (from the DARPANet onwards) was to ensure that you don't have all your eggs in one basket. Use multiple Availability Zones, and - if your architecture can afford it - multiple suppliers.

Our business has multiple services with a mix of "close to the metal" (for production) and virtual (for backup and staging) environments, and we use virtual environments (including Rackspace cloud) for development. It's all about performance and risk management.
DJ
May 2, 2011 6:50 PM
Too many nuffies pushing the "cloud world" as the new way of outsourcing.

When you move to the cloud you put your systems in the hands of someone else - beware.

Maintain backups and your own copies of anything you outsource.... or pay the price when the "cloud" rains and takes your business systems offline.

If it sounds too good to be true.....
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
 
Top Stories
Australian miners send drones to work
In-depth: Unmanned aerial vehicles in the resources sector.
 
The New Zealand telco problem
Opinion: Could Telstra save Kiwi telcos?
 
IT price probe to 'name and shame' gougers
Industry ducking the issue, committee claims.
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Should the Government enact new legislation to protect copyright holders in the digital age?

   |   View results
Yes
  19%
 
No
  81%
TOTAL VOTES: 510

Vote