Ocker YouTube star spared defamation row

 

Defamation action reportedly shelved after YouTube video pulled.

Queensland IT repairman Pete Finn claims to have been spared a defamation suit after getting into hot water over the posting of an inflammatory YouTube video which took aim at a Queensland Hotel.

Finn runs Noosaville-based Pete's PC Repairs by day, but is more known around the world by 22,000 subscribers to his YouTube channel, Fat Aussie Barstard [sic].

Finn was threatened with defamation action earlier this week after posting a negative review of a Brisbane hotel on YouTube.

The review, recorded under Finn's online alter ego Fat Aussie Barstard (sic), criticised South Bank's Plough Inn for what Finn described as poor service during a gathering at the establishment, organised in conjunction with Google-owned YouTube.

Finn learned that the proprietor of the hotel planned to sue him for defamation via an article in The Sunday Mail.

Finn took the video down after 24-hours online.

He said today that he most certainly used some explosive language in the review – accusing the hotel staff of being a "pack of c***'s", among other expletives. But Finn said his online character is "deliberately rude, crude and politically incorrect".

"The last time I checked, calling someone a bad name isn't illegal," he said.

Within hours of posting a response to the threat of defamation on YouTube, Finn was approached by mainstream media outlets such as A Current Affair and publications from the United States, Japan and Canada.

"Had [The Plough Hotel] had a win in the courts, it would have had a huge impact on social media in Australia – on free speech," Finn said.

It would also impact YouTube users around the world, he said.

"If people start getting sued for videos on YouTube, Google would have to change their community guidelines."

Finn's legion of online fans posted numerous videos in his defence.

He claims that journalists from A Current Affair have since informed Finn that the litigation has been dropped.

"I don't think [the hotel] realised the power of YouTube," Finn said.

A spokesman for the Plough Inn said it would be making no comment after repeatedly being misquoted by the press.

The controversy appears to be paying off for Finn – who aside from his computer repair business, profits from merchandising. He sells t-shirts, underwear and other merchandise stamped with Fat Aussie Barstard's image and provocative slogans such as "We're full!" on a map of Australia.

He also said that as part of YouTube's partnership program, he has been earning a few hundred dollars a month – and in October alone took a cheque for over $4,000.

His December earnings are sure to make for a Merry Christmas.

Copyright © CRN Australia . All rights reserved.


Ocker YouTube star spared defamation row
"This is a disgrace. If a person receives what he considers to be bad service, then he has every right to make public criticism of it. Under defamation laws in Australia, truth is a statutory ..."
By ziggyzap
 
 
 
Comments: 1
ziggyzap
Dec 25, 2010 6:59 AM
This is a disgrace. If a person receives what he considers to be bad service, then he has every right to make public criticism of it. Under defamation laws in Australia, truth is a statutory defence and the only feasible way to defeat the truth defence is to show that the alleged defamation was malicious.

However, making valid criticism using comedy does not mean that there was malice intended.

I have criticised many things on my own websites and I challenge anybody to sue me for them. In fact one guy did do that and I eventually took him to the cleaners and bankrupted him in a lengthy NSW Supreme Court.

Freedom of speech and freedom to criticise are inherent to our way of life and nobody should be intimidated into not panning lousy service or shoddy goods.
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
 
Top Stories
Australian miners send drones to work
In-depth: Unmanned aerial vehicles in the resources sector.
 
The New Zealand telco problem
Opinion: Could Telstra save Kiwi telcos?
 
IT price probe to 'name and shame' gougers
Industry ducking the issue, committee claims.
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
Polls
Should the Government enact new legislation to protect copyright holders in the digital age?

   |   View results
Yes
  19%
 
No
  81%
TOTAL VOTES: 510

Vote