Nintendo wins lawsuit over R4 mod chip piracy

Feb 18, 2010 9:48 AM
Tags: nintendo | r4 | mod | chip | modchip | gadgetgear | federal | court | rsj it solutions

Settled out of court.

EXCLUSIVE - An Australian distributor has been ordered to pay Nintendo over half a million dollars for selling  video game piracy tool, the R4 mod chip.

The Federal Court ordered that RSJ IT Solutions cease to sell the chip through its gadgetgear.com.au site and any other sites it controlled, as well as paying Nintendo $520,000 in damages.

The chip allows users to circumvent the technology protection measures Nintendo has built into its DS handheld consoles, enabling illegally pirated games to be downloaded online.

Nintendo brought the claim against the gadget accessory distributor and two affiliated respondents Patrick Li and James Li.

The court's ruling further excluded the individual respondents from selling their R4 chips anywhere in Australia, while also ordering them to pay Nintendo an additional $100,000.

They have also been required to file an affidavit by the end of this week identifying all suppliers from whom they purchased their R4 chips.

The R4 is built to fit into the game cartridge slot of Nintendo's DS, and will transfer anything saved on a flash memory chip onto the console. There are even videos on YouTube providing R4 tutorials for first-time users.

R4 chips have plagued Nintendo since their widespread adoption in 2007 and continue to be easily available online. While gadgetgear simply stocked the R4 chip, other distributors have made the piracy process even easier for consumers by pre-loading their R4 chips with ready-to-use counterfeit games.

Australian site Oz Mod Chips offers a range of products that will modify games consoles, enabling them to access pirated games. The distributor advises consumers to use their modification devices for legal reasons only, such as playing legal copies of games from different regions, using homebrew software, and playing backups of games that UPDATbeen legally purchased.

It is the second battle Nintendo has won in the Federal Court over game piracy in little over a week. On February 9,  a Brisbane man was ordered by the court to pay Nintendo $1.5 million for uploading a copy of the Super Mario Bros game for the Nintendo Wii to the internet prior to its Australian release.

UPDATE - The two parties have since informed us that the matter was settled out of court, but in such a manner that the Judge was still permitted to pass down an order. Technically, our original standfirst suggesting that the R4 chip is now illegal may be incorrect.


  • Email a Friend
  • Print Page
Nintendo wins lawsuit over R4 mod chip piracy
"Just so Nintendo aren't let off the leash so easily here, everyone should be aware that modding your Wii to play region-locked Wii and GameCube games is 100% legal =) Latest Wii chip is the ..."
By Bourkie
 
 
Comments: 7
Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
Bourkie
Feb 18, 2010 12:35 PM
Nintendo won because the DS is not region coded - so the law doesn't protect you.

For consoles that are region coded you are still allowed to chip them if you circumvent the region coding (possible on Wii, 360, PSP, PS2 and GameCube).
meski
Feb 18, 2010 2:41 PM
The date caught my eye - 2007? Is this still a current console?
sabredog66
Feb 18, 2010 3:07 PM
So the DS:TT is still legal?

Interesting.....
Bourkie
Feb 18, 2010 3:17 PM
DSi is region locked, so you can mod it legally...

Only the DS and DS Lite are region free - so you can't mod them legally.
btone
Feb 18, 2010 6:02 PM
Tanya, I thought the $1.5m case was settled out of court between the parties, not a court decision or order?
tasscorpio
Feb 22, 2010 6:34 PM
I bought the unit to more easily allow the kids to listen to music or play videos - hell why didn't nintendo offer a multimedia chip to do the same ? -
Bourkie
Feb 23, 2010 11:47 AM
Just so Nintendo aren't let off the leash so easily here, everyone should be aware that modding your Wii to play region-locked Wii and GameCube games is 100% legal =)

Latest Wii chip is the WiiKey Fusion:
http://wiikey.cn/en/
Comment:
Want to participate in the discussion?
Or log in now to comment
 
 
 
Top Stories
Oracle shuts down open source test servers
Playing nice with the open source community, Larry?
 
Google hosts election debate
Lundy, Fletcher and Ludlam face off on tech policies.
 
Telstra fined $18.5m for exchange access
Kept competitive DSLAM kit out.
 

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Latest Comments
"anyone who knows ANYTHING about RF knows how idiotic it is to have a "bare" antennae that will ..."
by Res Jul 31, 2010 10:00 AM
 
"Now Julia, if only you would promise not to filter the internet in your next term of government ..."
by hsvandrew Jul 31, 2010 9:33 AM
 
"@Nate - my fears are that if we use a national consortium as an interface to international ..."
by heavenlyhaloes Jul 31, 2010 12:41 AM
 
"Did anybody notice that on Apple's website the iPhone is missing the AT&T logo on the top bar? ..."
by brownenicola Jul 30, 2010 10:18 PM
 
"@digger11 - when will you learn just to remain quiet when you don't have all the facts or a ..."
by Bazwalt Jul 30, 2010 7:13 PM
Polls
Did Google breach the Telecommunications Interception or Privacy Acts during its WiFi wardrive?

   |   View results
Yes. There is no excuse for collecting this data.
  28%
 
No. If your wireless network is unsecured, you have no right to complain
  72%
TOTAL VOTES: 1873

Vote