iTnews

Optus warns decryption bill contains 'unfettered' power

By Ry Crozier on Sep 22, 2018 10:53AM
Optus warns decryption bill contains 'unfettered' power

Can change terms of voluntary cooperation agreements on-the-fly.

Optus has issued a blunt warning about “unfettered” power that proposed decryption laws could hand authorities to unilaterally change or revoke voluntary cooperation agreements without consultation.

In a submission [pdf] to the Department of Home Affairs, Optus largely avoids the wider issues that the decryption bill raises.

These, it says, are “ultimately a matter for Government to find the right balance between … the extension of the power of the state over the individual; the associated tension with privacy principles and civil liberties; and the utility of the access to communications for law enforcement and national security agencies”.

However, Optus was unhappy with aspects of the bill including a lack of consultation with the subject of a request or notice.

It wants mandatory consultation to be included at all stages to prevent agencies from going overboard, particularly in specifying what may or may not be technically feasible.

Optus is also concerned that law enforcement is afforded too much discretionary power, particularly when it comes to the voluntary “technical assistance requests” that can be served.

“If the power of the authorised person to vary a technical assistance request is unfettered, then a service provider is faced with the risk that a variation can be made without prior consultation, leaving it with a commitment to provide assistance it may not have agreed to in the first instance and that it does not have the capability to perform,” Optus said.

It said the unannounced variation could be costly, technically complex or impossible, or break the functioning of Optus’ network.

“Any one of these factors could alter the balance of the service provider’s original decision to enter into a voluntary agreement and could, in fact, place the service provider in the difficult circumstance of having to meet agreed or contracted commitments which have been unilaterally varied,” it said.

Similar powers exist for the authorities to unilaterally revoke a request, again without consulting the service provider or other party affected by it.

Optus said it also wants the government to come up with a standard form of contract that can be used in all agreements made under the laws (assuming they pass).

Importantly, Optus said it did not want to provide voluntary assistance “in advance of commercial contracting arrangements being agreed and settled”.

It is unclear in the legislation when a telco that struck a voluntary agreement would have to begin implementing it.

Expense and distraction

Optus warned that compliance with the decryption laws was likely to be an expensive and time-consuming proposition for telcos.

The costs of maintaining its existing internal law enforcement liaison unit were already “substantial”, without the significant imposition of the proposed decryption laws.

Optus also warned that its forward plans could be thrown into disarray by the decryption laws, if passed.

“Optus already has major commercial, IT and network programs in flight and which are scheduled for implementation over the next three years,” it said.

“In practical terms, the assistance regime may disrupt these plans.

“Optus will need to stand prepared to initiate significant scoping and compliance programs in response to this assistance regime.”

Got a news tip for our journalists? Share it with us anonymously here.
Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.
Tags:
bill decryption law enforcement networking optus power security telco/isp unfettered unilateral

Partner Content

Beat the DDoS blackmails in 2021
Promoted Content Beat the DDoS blackmails in 2021
Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
Partner Content Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
Putting cyber security basics in place
Partner Content Putting cyber security basics in place
What conversations should executives be having about cyber security?
Partner Content What conversations should executives be having about cyber security?

Sponsored Whitepapers

The top 5 tech trends to deliver business outcomes
The top 5 tech trends to deliver business outcomes
10 reasons why businesses need to invest in cloud security training
10 reasons why businesses need to invest in cloud security training
Your guide to application security solutions
Your guide to application security solutions
State of Software Security: Open Source Edition
State of Software Security: Open Source Edition
Five questions to ask before you upgrade to a SIEM solution
Five questions to ask before you upgrade to a SIEM solution

Events

  • On-Demand Webinar: How Poly and Microsoft are Embracing Future Work Environments
  • [iTnews and Micro Focus] Navigating the cloud modernisation minefield
By Ry Crozier
Sep 22 2018
10:53AM
0 Comments

Related Articles

  • Optus filed half of all network change notifications under security laws
  • Telstra frets network breakage, trust breaches from decryption laws
  • China-backed telecom firm says won't spy on Philippines
  • Special Report: Cyber-intel firms pitch governments on spy tools to trace coronavirus
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Whatsapp Email A Friend

Most Read Articles

TPG Telecom to start enticing NBN customers to move

TPG Telecom to start enticing NBN customers to move

Infosys scores another $40m for Centrelink payments engine build

Infosys scores another $40m for Centrelink payments engine build

Telstra InfraCo opens up telco's own fibre network

Telstra InfraCo opens up telco's own fibre network

Transport for NSW data stolen in Accellion breach

Transport for NSW data stolen in Accellion breach

You must be a registered member of iTnews to post a comment.
Log In | Register
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.