iTnews

Industry warns site blocking could have unintended consequences

By Allie Coyne on Mar 26, 2015 3:21PM
Industry warns site blocking could have unintended consequences

Highlight need to avoid ASIC blunder.

Australia's internet and telecommunications industries have warned the Government's plan to allow content holders to apply for piracy websites to be blocked could have negative unintended consequences.

Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull today introduced the Copyright Amendment (Online Infringement) Bill into the lower house.

The bill will amend the Copyright Act to allow rights holders to apply for overseas websites used for downloading and uploading copyright infringing content to be blocked.

The Communications Alliance and the Internet Society of Australia - representative groups of the telco and internet industries - separately said their constituents had not been consulted in the drafting of the bill and were today examining its contents for the first time.

Comms Alliance CEO John Stanton said the telco and ISP industry had given its "conditional support" for the initiative, but said site blocking was a "relatively blunt tool" that could result in collateral damage if not applied carefully.

The bill does not offer any guidelines for the technical method in which ISPs should block a website. 

“The bill should, for example, ensure that “online location” is precisely defined, to reduce the risk that websites may be unintentionally impacted when multiple websites reside under a single IP address or domain,” Stanton said.

Such an issue arose in 2013 when corporate regulator ASIC inadvertently blocked 250,000 websites in an attempt to block 1200.

It later revealed that its team responsible for using powers under section 313 of the Telecommunications Act to block websites had not been aware a single IP address could host multiple websites.

Stanton said the Government should also ensure ISPs were legally indemnified by rights holders against actions they are required to take to comply with a site-blocking ruling.

The Government estimates the site blocking scheme would cost internet service providers around $130,000 per year. It will not provide any compensation for compliance.

Stanton said the industry was not happy with having another cost forced upon it - adding to the hundreds of millions it will have to spend to comply with the Government's data retention scheme, as well as the Government-mandated industry code to tackle copyright infringement.

“We are yet to see the detail of this [$130,000] estimate but believe that additional cost for ISPs assisting the fight against copyright infringement should be avoided," Stanton said.

CEO of the Internet Society of Australia Laurie Patton labelled the site blocking bill "a little excessive".

 " .. so we've asked the Government to consult with us in order to make sure there are no negative unintended consequences," he said.

"We'd want to be sure cases can only proceed when there is a clear breach of copyright.

"Just because you've used something like BitTorrent doesn't automatically mean you've breached the Copyright Act."

Rights holders would need to prove to a judge that the "primary purpose" of the site in question was to faciliate copyright infringement.

Patton said the society had offered its technical advice to the Government to make sure MPs fully understood the bill's implications.

"It's important for Parliament to understand how the internet actually works or we risk flawed legislation like the data retention bill that ends up having to be amended at the last minute," he said.

The bill has been referred to a Senate committee review, which will undertake consultation with industry before reporting in six weeks.

Got a news tip for our journalists? Share it with us anonymously here.
Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.
Tags:
asic copyright infringement piracy piracy code security site blocking

Partner Content

Beat the DDoS blackmails in 2021
Partner Content Beat the DDoS blackmails in 2021
Why companies fail at picking cloud modernisation partners
Partner Content Why companies fail at picking cloud modernisation partners
Shut the door on ransomware
Partner Content Shut the door on ransomware
MSI shows first laptops with Wi-Fi 6E, Nvidia RTX 30 graphics
Partner Content MSI shows first laptops with Wi-Fi 6E, Nvidia RTX 30 graphics

Sponsored Whitepapers

Five questions to ask before you upgrade to a SIEM solution
Five questions to ask before you upgrade to a SIEM solution
Effectively addressing advanced threats
Effectively addressing advanced threats
The risky business of open source
The risky business of open source
Ensure your e-signatures are legally binding
Ensure your e-signatures are legally binding
Mitigating open source risk in your organisation
Mitigating open source risk in your organisation

Events

  • On-Demand Webinar: How Poly and Microsoft are Embracing Future Work Environments
  • Beat the DDoS blackmailers in 2021
By Allie Coyne
Mar 26 2015
3:21PM
0 Comments

Related Articles

  • ASIC sues financial services company for repeated hacks
  • CBA reveals screen scrapers double its customer fraud propensity
  • ANZ tries to defuse screen scraping time bomb
  • SonicWall discloses "coordinated attack" on internal systems
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Whatsapp Email A Friend

Most Read Articles

Australia Post is building a digital twin of its delivery network

Australia Post is building a digital twin of its delivery network

Google threatens to withdraw search engine in Australia

Google threatens to withdraw search engine in Australia

Trump pardons former Google self-driving car engineer

Trump pardons former Google self-driving car engineer

NBN Co runs fixed wireless tower on diesel generator for over two years

NBN Co runs fixed wireless tower on diesel generator for over two years

You must be a registered member of iTnews to post a comment.
Log In | Register
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.