iTnews

Public servants no match for IBM, says former minister

By Charis Palmer on May 31, 2013 11:56AM
Public servants no match for IBM, says former minister

Lawsuit not a viable option.

Suing IBM over the failed Queensland Health payroll project would likely have turned into a time-consuming “he said, she said” debacle, according to former Queensland health minister Paul Lucas.

Lucas took to the stand yesterday on the last formal day of hearings in the Commission of Inquiry investigating the bungled payroll system replacement project, which is expected to cost Queensland taxpayers more than $1.2 billion to fix.

Asked repeatedly why the state had not pursued litigation with IBM, Lucas, who practiced law prior to becoming a minister, continually highlighted the concern that suing IBM would not help ensure Health employees got paid correctly.

“If I thought that we could have sued IBM and
 not had a risk or a downside with respect to our staff then that would have been a completely different picture, but it wasn't like that,” Lucas told the inquiry.

“This would
 turn ultimately on who said what to whom, in what meeting
 when, what was reasonably within it, and that was simply a very, very complex thing that ultimately might be resolved by questions of credit,” he said.

He said had legal action been taken rather than an inquiry, the State would still be in a trial today.

When later pressed on the issue, Lucas also said public servants could not be called upon as reliable witnesses.

“Many public servants are not skilled or educated in relation to the commercial realities of dealing with other people. Someone like IBM, it is their bread and butter, they do it every week.”

Lucas told the inquiry he shared the view held by former Public Works Director-General Mal Grierson that the payroll system may have fallen over should IBM walk from the project.

“His effect was that, "If
 we don't settle, you know, these guys will walk away from 
it. You know what the consequences of that is, we need 
them."

Click here for full coverage of the Queesland Health payroll inquiry.

Got a news tip for our journalists? Share it with us anonymously here.
Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.
Tags:
contract corptech health ibm inquiry law lucas payroll qhinquiry qld qld vs ibm training & development

Partner Content

One way SD-WAN can save business leaders' time
Partner Content One way SD-WAN can save business leaders' time
Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
Partner Content Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
Putting cyber security basics in place
Partner Content Putting cyber security basics in place
Setting a path to self-funded mainframe-to-cloud modernisation with Micro Focus
Promoted Content Setting a path to self-funded mainframe-to-cloud modernisation with Micro Focus

Sponsored Whitepapers

Empowering workforces in the new environment
Empowering workforces in the new environment
Is the technology refresh dead?
Is the technology refresh dead?
DevSecOps: A framework for digital innovation
DevSecOps: A framework for digital innovation
Encryption: Protect your most critical data
Encryption: Protect your most critical data
Overcoming data security challenges in a hybrid, multicloud world
Overcoming data security challenges in a hybrid, multicloud world

Events

  • On-Demand Webinar: How Poly and Microsoft are Embracing Future Work Environments
  • [Webinar] - Transformation versus compliance – a guide for CXOs
  • Masters of Microsoft Licensing
  • Is your DevSecOps stuck in first gear?
By Charis Palmer
May 31 2013
11:56AM
0 Comments

Related Articles

  • QLD Health payroll will never be automated: IBM
  • QLD Health ignored IBM contract breaches
  • Canberra Health Services seeks CIO in newly created role
  • Swinburne University of Technology CTO switches to Bupa
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Whatsapp Email A Friend

Most Read Articles

Aussie Broadband says some customers are switching providers to get high-speed NBN discounts

Aussie Broadband says some customers are switching providers to get high-speed NBN discounts

Aussie Broadband to white label its services

Aussie Broadband to white label its services

Swinburne University data breach exposes details of 5000 staff, students

Swinburne University data breach exposes details of 5000 staff, students

CBA's digital benefits finder unlocks $481 million for customers

CBA's digital benefits finder unlocks $481 million for customers

You must be a registered member of iTnews to post a comment.
Log In | Register
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.