iTnews

Day 19: iiNet tries to show disbalance in studio demands

By Ry Crozier on Nov 13, 2009 12:21PM
Day 19: iiNet tries to show disbalance in studio demands

Sample accounts don’t download many films and TV shows.

ISP iiNet will argue the “reasonable steps” that the film industry proposes the ISP take are disproportionate to the number of infringements recorded against a sample of 20 user accounts.

The ISP’s lead barrister Richard Cobden commenced closing statements in the Federal Court today - the first time in over a fortnight he had spoken, apart from a brief re-examination of iiNet chief Michael Malone last week.

Cobden said the outcome of iiNet’s closing submissions would be that the “very large number of infringements that the applicants are fond of identifying” would be reduced - “but not to some trivial number that the applicants should not be concerned about.

“But for a number of reasons [the number] is not going to be anything like the applicants say,” Cobden claimed.

He claimed that a sample of 20 iiNet user accounts provided to the film industry revealed the accounts “might” average two or three film or TV episode downloads over the film studio’s 59-week investigation.

“It’s clear from the accounts that ultimately the [infringing] activity is likely to account for a very modest percentage of that user’s activity [and] a very modest percentage of their quota,” Cobden alleged.

“And really if one bores through the welter of detail in the AFACT spreadsheets, what it looks like over the 59-week investigation period that there might be an average per user of two or three films or TV shows.

“None of that amounts to the dramatic sorts of infringement that the applicants speak of”, Cobden alleged, nor did it confirm the film industry’s allegations that infringing activities were driving users onto higher quota plans, from which iiNet profited.

“We wouldn’t suggest that two or three films over 59 weeks per account is something the applicants or the court should not be concerned about,” Cobden claimed.

But he alleged that on balance, the steps that the film industry has suggested iiNet perform - which include warning, ‘playpenning’ of an account or termination - were disproportionate  to the amount of allegedly infringing acts or the proportion of activity they represented on the sample user accounts.

“On balance it’s not something that requires iiNet to do anything to the nature of what the industry wants iiNet to do,” Cobden alleged.

It was understood Cobden would run through the majority of this part of its defence next week.

The case continues. You can follow the case in-full here. For a background on the case, click here.

Got a news tip for our journalists? Share it with us anonymously here.
Tags:
afact case cobden copyright iinet infringement numbers telco/isp

Partner Content

Apathetic leadership remains cybersecurity barrier in Australia
Promoted Content Apathetic leadership remains cybersecurity barrier in Australia
Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
Partner Content Tackling cybersecurity in 2021
What is zero trust cybersecurity?
Partner Content What is zero trust cybersecurity?
What conversations should executives be having about cyber security?
Partner Content What conversations should executives be having about cyber security?

Sponsored Whitepapers

Empowering workforces in the new environment
Empowering workforces in the new environment
Is the technology refresh dead?
Is the technology refresh dead?
DevSecOps: A framework for digital innovation
DevSecOps: A framework for digital innovation
Encryption: Protect your most critical data
Encryption: Protect your most critical data
Overcoming data security challenges in a hybrid, multicloud world
Overcoming data security challenges in a hybrid, multicloud world

Events

  • On-Demand Webinar: How Poly and Microsoft are Embracing Future Work Environments
  • [Webinar] - Transformation versus compliance – a guide for CXOs
  • Masters of Microsoft Licensing
  • Is your DevSecOps stuck in first gear?
By Ry Crozier
Nov 13 2009
12:21PM
0 Comments

Related Articles

  • Aussie Broadband looks for CVC upside from 'white label' customers
  • Aussie Broadband says some customers are switching providers to get high-speed NBN discounts
  • Optus creates senior leadership role spanning national and cyber security ops
  • Aussie Broadband to white label its services
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Whatsapp Email A Friend

Most Read Articles

Aussie Broadband says some customers are switching providers to get high-speed NBN discounts

Aussie Broadband says some customers are switching providers to get high-speed NBN discounts

Aussie Broadband to white label its services

Aussie Broadband to white label its services

Swinburne University data breach exposes details of 5000 staff, students

Swinburne University data breach exposes details of 5000 staff, students

CBA's digital benefits finder unlocks $481 million for customers

CBA's digital benefits finder unlocks $481 million for customers

You must be a registered member of iTnews to post a comment.
Log In | Register
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed in any form without prior authorisation.
Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of nextmedia's Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.