The three-year struggle between BlackBerry manufacturer Research In Motion and the Indian Government over what can remain private continues to be played out in public.
After months of debate over India's demands for RIM to provide access to its proprietary enterprise services and encrypted emails, Research in Motion linked the dispute to India's economic outlook.
In a note to its enterprise customers in late February, the smartphone maker wrote that a ban on its operations would affect India's financial development and its outsourcing opportunities. Noting that other companies – including Nokia, Motorola, Apple, Sony Ericsson and HTC – offer wireless services with similar types of encryption technologies, RIM contended that every supplier should abide by the same rules.
India responded a week later by sharing an internal telecommunications department document with The Economic Times. It said that, although Research in Motion had recently provided encryption keys for its messaging and internet services to Indian security officials, the company had not provided enough technical detail to permit sufficient access.
The Government repeated its position that Research in Motion set up an enterprise server in India, something it said the company was considering. The internal document said that a technical committee was established to study the architecture of other service providers' networks, but did not commit to applying the same scrutiny to all mobile carriers.
In January, Research in Motion suspended its discussions with the Indian Government, contending that officials in the country were leaking sensitive information to the media to undermine the Canadian company's position.
The Department of Telecommunications dismissed that charge as a delaying tactic on the Candian company's part.