Privacy review blasts app terms

 

Google and LinkedIn are riskiest.

A privacy researcher and visiting academic at the University of NSW has called for consumer protections to counter poor terms of service by mainstream cloud services and internet providers.

Cyberspace law and policy professor Roger Clarke reviewed the terms of use for six applications - Google Apps, Yahoo!, Microsoft Live, Dropbox, LinkedIn, Zoho Apps - and internet providers Internode, iiNet and Infinite.

Eight of the nine providers made their terms of service available on their websites but each site asserted a right to unilaterally change terms, found Clarke who is a visiting academic in the law faculty at UNSW and runs policy consultancy Xamax.

For three of those services - iiNet, Internode and Microsoft Live - notice was provided in advance and by user-convenient means and the change was to be explained rather than the new terms being declared.

For Google, Infinite, LinkedIn, Yahoo! and Zoho, notice was not provided. Instead, an announcement was made somewhere on the website which had immediate effect.

“Hence, for at least five of the nine suppliers in the sample, consumers are unlikely to even know, let alone understand, the terms that are applicable at any given time,” Clarke's review found.

Dropbox did not publish terms of use on its website.

The review found Google's terms were scattered “across about 80 documents” and in many circumstances it was unclear when terms were applicable.

User-generated data

Clarke deemed protections for user-generated data in apps were poor.

"My findings are that none of the nine providers satisfy all of the reasonable expectations of users and that the terms of two major players - Google and LinkedIn - satisfy none of the expectations," he said.

Only Internode, iiNet and Yahoo! had terms that provided them no right to use a customer's data.

Dropbox limited use of customer data to "access" - although it was unclear what that meant.

Infinite and Zoho authorised use of customer data related to their contract with the user.

Microsoft Live's terms authorised use of customer data "to provide the service", which Clarke said could be interpreted as being the service as a whole not just that provided to the user.

Google and LinkedIn claimed substantial rights against user data.

Clarke also found each app or service provider asserted rights to disclose customer data to a business partner. The scope of that term was capable of "very liberal interpretation", he said.

“In the case of Google and LinkedIn – basically they can do anything they want. It’s just not limited. It’s absolutely horrendous,” he said.

Regulation calls

Clarke concluded that consumer protections would "appear to be essential, given the power imbalance" and the importance of internet services and apps.

But he was pessimistic at the prospect of regulators acting.

Attempts to regulate would be undermined by the transnational nature of services, the dominance of US marketing, the pro-corporate and anti-consumer stance of US regulators and meek regulators in other countries, he said.

Most of all there was "a lack of organised resistance by consumer representative and advocacy bodies" on the issue.

“Serious consumer disappointments and recriminations against outsourcing and cloud-sourcing providers would seem to be inevitable,” Clarke said.

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


Privacy review blasts app terms
Senator Joe Ludwig hands Roger Clarke (right) the Australian Privacy Medal, 2009.
 
 
 
Top Stories
IBM, NEC picked for major NSW Transport deals
Final contract negotiations begin.
 
Govt proposes crackdown on ISPs over piracy
Wants new legal powers for copyright industry.
 
Westpac interim CIO resigns
Group CIO yet to be appointed.
 
 
Senator Joe Ludwig hands Roger Clarke (right) the Australian Privacy Medal, 2009.
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...
Latest articles on BIT Latest Articles from BIT
Pass on carbon tax savings, warns ACCC
Jul 24, 2014
The ACCC is warning businesses that supply "regulated goods" to pass on any cost savings ...
Have customers that won't pay debts?
Jul 10, 2014
The ACCC and ASIC have updated their advice when it comes to collecting debts.
Carpet cleaner faces court over online testimonials
Jul 4, 2014
The ACCC has initiated proceedings against A Whistle (1979) Pty Ltd, the franchisor of Electrodry...
You can now get 15GB of free online storage using Microsoft OneDrive
Jun 25, 2014
Cloud storage has reached both the capacity and price where it's a viable alternative to local ...
Another clever trick you can perform with Xero
Jun 25, 2014
Here is another way to reach out to particular subsets of your customers using Xero.
Latest Comments
Polls
What is delaying adoption of public cloud in your organisation?







   |   View results
Lock-in concerns
  30%
 
Application integration concerns
  3%
 
Security and compliance concerns
  27%
 
Unreliable network infrastructure
  9%
 
Data sovereignty concerns
  21%
 
Lack of stakeholder support
  3%
 
Protecting on-premise IT jobs
  4%
 
Difficulty transitioning CapEx budget into OpEx
  3%
TOTAL VOTES: 1000

Vote