Turnbull attempts to change Telstra split bill

 

Last ditch effort to stall and thwart bill with more amendments.

Opposition communications spokesman Malcolm Turnbull has made a last-ditch attempt to put the Coalition's stamp on the Telstra split bill by pushing a fresh round of changes that – if agreed to - would delay its passing this year.

UPDATE: 3pm - The Telstra split bill has been approved by the House of Representatives.

The amendments included another push by the Coalition for a Productivity Commission-led cost benefit analysis – introduced as a "new part 10" to the proposed bill.

"What this amendment does is seek to spend taxpayers' funds wisely," Turnbull said.

On the final day of parliament's sitting for the year, the Government faced one more battle to have the House of Representatives agree to the Senate's amendments on the Telstra split bill.

The bill finally passed the Senate after a marathon debate late last week.

The Coalition largely failed to get any of its amendments incorporated in the Senate and appeared to be trying once more, leading to more accusations by the ALP over the Coalition's stalling tactics.

"There are no lengths to which the Opposition will go to deny the important structural separation of Telstra," Leader of the House Anthony Albanese said.

"The fact is we've had this debate. The fact is that the [Turnbull] says he supports the structural separation of Telstra and yet every measure is being put in the way of this legislation, even now it's been properly and fully considered by the House and the Senate with amendments."

Albanese said that accepting any of the amendments would delay the bill and the separation of Telstra.

He unsuccessfully sought a ruling to shut down debate over the relevance of the proposed amendments.

The first round of amendments proposed by Turnbull – a change to some wording in the proposed legislation, not the new cost-benefit section - was voted down 57-60 in a division.

The Opposition failed to mount a case for debate of Turnbull's remaining amendments, including the cost-benefit analysis.

However, an attempt by independent MP Andrew Wilkie to shut Turnbull down and force the vote on the senate amendments was unsuccessful. Debate was continuing on the bill.

More stalling tactics

The Coalition's push came after it earlier attempted to have a motion passed that would have suspended standing orders – including the final hurdle for the Telstra split bill.

That motion was also defeated narrowly but not before the Coalition copped a spray from independent MP Rob Oakeshott.

"I came here for the Telecommunications Legislation amendments," Oakeshott said.

"I did not come in for rhetoric over reality, for politics over policy."

Copyright © iTnews.com.au . All rights reserved.


Turnbull attempts to change Telstra split bill
"Noel peters I like how you forgot that the current opposition tried to hide the OPEL project with no business plan or any costings Hypocrisy from the coalition and thier supporters"
By sydney
 
 
 
Comments: 6
noelpeters
Nov 29, 2010 2:38 PM
Its quiet absurd and reckless that the Government would not do a cost benefit analysis but this is in character with Labor's approach to using taxpayer's money to further their socialist ideals and illusions. Oakeshott is a fraud in claiming he is acting in all Australians' interests. Telecommunications costs like water and electriity can only increase with Labor's plans.
mad1k5
Nov 29, 2010 3:10 PM
noelpeters,

Oakeshott is telling how it is, if you watched today, you would know that Coalition were trying to delay the Telstra Split, as they have done that already last week.

Costing the tax payers $600,000.

The issue is when Coalition does not want to shut up and move on, when the issue has been decided. Their Heroics, over CBA issue is getting tiring, and it's their excuse for not supporting either NBN or Telstra split.

If the Senate and House do not want a CBA(or at least Coalitions version of it), then it stands to reason that this project should go ahead.
HubertCumberdale
Nov 29, 2010 4:10 PM
oh noes another torrent of tears from the coalition, I guess the delaying tactic is the only thing they can really do now.
singo79
Nov 29, 2010 4:38 PM
@mad1K5 - Well said mate!

The coalition have stalled at every point and are just plain losers. Had a CBA been done on any government funded project in the past we would most likely not have the infrastructure that we have today.

A CBA is just another waste of public funds for the coalition to draw the NBN out as long as possible and to go to the next election and state that the Labor Government weren't able to deliver on any of their promises. The NBN would be further along today had it not been for a stupid and ignorant coalition standing in the way.

Get over it, you lost the election, the Telstra split legislation has gone through, there is absolutely no political gain in this area any further for you.
HubertCumberdale
Nov 29, 2010 5:17 PM
singo79 wrote:
A CBA is just another waste of public funds for the coalition to draw the NBN out as long as possible and to go to the next election and state that the Labor Government weren't able to deliver on any of their promises. The NBN would be further along today had it not been for a stupid and ignorant coalition standing in the way.

Nailed it and I dont think they realise that this sort of thing is eventually going to come back to bite them in the ass, they've set a precedent so now every time some infrastructure project is on the agenda either party not in power will be screaming "CBA! CBA! CBA!" nothing will ever get done, obviously they are more interested in their pride than the people who elect them.
sydney
Nov 29, 2010 5:26 PM
Noel peters


I like how you forgot that the current opposition tried to hide the OPEL project with no business plan or any costings

Hypocrisy from the coalition and thier supporters
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
Top Stories
Review: Microsoft Surface Pro
A year is a long time in the computer hardware business.
 
 
NBN Co could miss revised June fibre targets
Analysis: Cutting it fine in the race to the line.
 
 
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

iTnews Academy: Microsoft Windows Server 2012 - Hyper-V
iTnews Academy: Microsoft Windows Server 2012 - Hyper-V
Interview: Australia's 'cloud-last' policy is dangerous.
Interview: Australia's 'cloud-last' policy is dangerous.
Interview: Vivek Kundra on Australia's 'cloud last' policy
Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
To automatically deploy test/dev sandboxes by mid-year.
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Data safe with Human Services, CIO says.
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Technology chief shifts focus from building to leveraging systems.
VicRoads restructures IT team
VicRoads restructures IT team
Department moves to align with industry benchmarks.
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Malaysian staff served from Australian data centres.
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Yarra Valley Water CIO Leigh Berrell accepts his Benchmark Award for Utilities CIO of the Year.
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Domino's Pizza CIO Wayne McMahon accepts his Benchmark Award for Retail CIO of the Year.
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
CIO Jenny Levy discusses how outsourcing will help the firm "simplify, refocus and grow".
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Daniel McCabe, Assistant Secretary of Australia's Department of Defence, provides the audience at the iTnews Data Centre Strategy Summit with a deep dive into the organisation's data centre consolidation program.
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
The full keynote by Facebook data centre architect Marco Magarelli at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit. Magarelli details the design considerations behind the social network's Prineville, Oregon; North Carolina and Luleå, Sweden data centres.
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Telstra general manager of managed data centres Jon Curry guides the audience at the iTnews Australian Data Centre Summit through the build of the telco's Clayton, Victoria data centre.
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
Matthew Clark from the NSW Department of Environment guides facilties managers through the details of the new NABERS data centre energy rating tool at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit.
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
Matthew Clark (NSW Dept of Environment), Greg Boorer (Canberra Data Centres), Glenn Allan (National Australia Bank), Mike Andrea (Strategic Directions) and Bob Sharon (Green Global Consulting) discuss the impact of the NABERS data centre rating.
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Fortescue Metals 'New World of Work" project, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss the shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Pacific Aluminium's lightning fast service desk refresh, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Domino's Pizza's shift to hosted services, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss McDonald's Australia's new self-service portal for employees, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Latest Comments
Polls
Will you quit any cloud services in light of PRISM?

   |   View results
Yes
  59%
 
No
  41%
TOTAL VOTES: 86

Vote