Government savages Liberal plans to scrap the NBN

 

Abbott says NBN is "first to go" if Coalition returns to office.

The Federal Government has rounded on Liberal opposition leader Tony Abbott (pictured) after he announced plans to abandon the building of the National Broadband Network should the Coalition return to power in the Federal election.

Abbott's office has confirmed that he told the The Daily Telegraph the first thing to go in the Coalition's plans to slash public spending by $10 billion would be the $43 billion National Broadband Network (NBN).

While refusing to specify what will go, Abbott was quoted as saying that "if you want to cut spending, look at the NBN".

"Not proceeding with it could save billions of dollars," he told the Telegraph.

It provoked a swift response from Communications Minister Senator Stephen Conroy, who said that Abbott's plans to stop building the NBN would place the country's economic future in jeopardy.

"The NBN is crucial economic infrastructure," Senator Conroy said. "Without it, Australian companies will not be able to compete with the likes of Japan, Korea or Singapore."

He added that scrapping the NBN would also threaten the estimated 25,000 jobs that will be supported every year of the NBN rollout.

Labor Senator Kate Lundy said Abbott's announcement was "quite shocking to everyone associated with IT and telecommunications".

"Up until now [the Coalition has] obfuscated in the Senate, but now they've made the statement that they would not proceed with the construction of the NBN," Lundy said.

She countered the Coalition's argument that the NBN should be funded by private enterprise rather than the taxpayer.

"First of all, it was clear that private enterprise was not funding it," she said. "The private sector was unable to realise the raft of additional benefits to the economy and society that a public investment in the network can make," she said, adding that the conditions attached to private investment would "depress competition at the retail end of the market".

Lundy also quoted Telstra executives as saying that the country's copper network existed at a "five minutes to midnight" stage in terms of becoming obsolete.

"I think it's fair to say that there was consensus that the capacity to optimise the existing copper network had reached an end point and that fibre was the most future-proof technology that we could invest in," she added.

Senator Conroy said the NBN was in full swing, with about 500 kilometres of a proposed 6000 kilometres of optical fibre for regional Australia laid.

A spokesmaon for Abbott's office confirmed the comments were made by the Opposition Leader, but that he would not be commenting further on the issue. 


Government savages Liberal plans to scrap the NBN
Tony Abbott
"What hypocracy - Labour have conveniently forgotten the public money they wasted canning the original Broadband Connect contract when they got into government - a project which would have already ..."
By CommsRascal
 
 
 
Comments: 7
MerariSchroeder
Apr 29, 2010 3:05 PM
This article is full of Labor spin. The Librals didn't say they'd abandon communication infrastructure altogether. They said that they would invest in rural Australia, and provide grants to the private sector to establish FTTP.

So instead of there being a $43bn hit on tax-payers, it would be more like a $5bn hit, and we'd still get the same outcome.

As for the NBN being in "full swing" - That's all backhaul, and if it is scrapped and we finally get a look at the implementation study, we'll find the Labor government has yet again wasted more money. Maybe we'll be able to sell what is laid to a private communications company like Soul or something.
BrettWinterford
Apr 29, 2010 3:47 PM
@ Merari - this was my concern too, but Abbott's office confirmed with us that he made the comment. I should have included the Telegraph link - here it is. http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/national/abbotts-razor-plan-to-pay-off-our-debts/story-e6freuzr-1225859062130
MerariSchroeder
Apr 30, 2010 9:28 AM
Another alternative to "scrapping" the NBN, would be to replace it with a backhaul only plan. I'm sure anyone scrapping a multi-million dollar project won't just write it off, they'll extract as much value from it as possible.

"He added that scrapping the NBN would also threaten the estimated 25,000 jobs that will be supported every year of the NBN rollout."

That all sounded good during the peak of the recession, but now that all sounds inflationary. Those jobs would be payed for by tax payers, and i'm sure for every job you create in a wholesale NBNCo you must be offsetting in the private industry anyway. Eg. Bob leaves Telstra to work for NBNCo.
jumping jack
Apr 30, 2010 1:59 PM
I know this is an amazing thing to suggest, but why doesn't the gov just buy Telstra back?
Paranoid Android
May 13, 2010 8:29 PM
jack, spending money on telstra would achieve nothing, and probably cost twice as much as rolling out the NBN with far less benefits

Marari, getting halfway there isn't worth anything to anyone, Australians and Australian businesses want the FTTH infrastructure in place so that they can remain competitive with equivalent markets overseas.

also, when 'Bob' heads from telstra to NBNCo, who replaces them at telstra? or does telstra just dissolve in your mind when NBN springs up?
Digger11
May 14, 2010 8:40 AM
This is really really bad. I am now totally stuck on who to vote for.
1. Vote Liberal and give Telstra it's Monopoly back or
2. Vote Labor and have to put up with their total and utter incompetence for another 3 years.

This really is the proverbial rock and hard place.

Equivalency with overseas market has proven to be a rubbish argument, ADSL2+ works fine and we do not currently have the population density of a Hong Kong or Tokyo to give us all fast broadband (although with record population growth and property developers going berserk, it might not be long before we do).

CommsRascal
May 14, 2010 12:31 PM
What hypocracy - Labour have conveniently forgotten the public money they wasted canning the original Broadband Connect contract when they got into government - a project which would have already delivered broadband to the vast majority of the Australian population including rural users, had they stuck with it.

Instead, we're left with a "one day" network which they can't tell us the cost of, can't tell us whether Telstra will be involved and can't tell us where and when it will arrive.

More spin than a Shane Warne leg-break, more hypocritical than a teetotal pub-owner...
Comments have been disabled for this article.
 
 
Top Stories
Project management lessons from the QLD Health payroll inquiry
Analysis: How not to run a major IT project.
 
Review: Asus Fonepad
Calling on the Big Phone.
 
Photos: Highlights from SAP Sapphire Now 2013
All the keynote action from one of the world's biggest SAP events.
 
 
Tony Abbott
Sign up to receive iTnews email bulletins
   FOLLOW US...

Latest VideosSee all videos »

Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
Bankwest builds continuous delivery capability
To automatically deploy test/dev sandboxes by mid-year.
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Veterans' Affairs sets sights on modernisation
Data safe with Human Services, CIO says.
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Citi Australia drops platform customisations
Technology chief shifts focus from building to leveraging systems.
VicRoads restructures IT team
VicRoads restructures IT team
Department moves to align with industry benchmarks.
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Zurich Australia extends IT team offshore
Malaysian staff served from Australian data centres.
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Leigh Berrell - Utilities CIO of the Year
Yarra Valley Water CIO Leigh Berrell accepts his Benchmark Award for Utilities CIO of the Year.
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Wayne McMahon - Retail CIO of the Year
Domino's Pizza CIO Wayne McMahon accepts his Benchmark Award for Retail CIO of the Year.
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
Inside Perpetual's ongoing IT transformation
CIO Jenny Levy discusses how outsourcing will help the firm "simplify, refocus and grow".
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Managing Complexity - Defence's Daniel McCabe
Daniel McCabe, Assistant Secretary of Australia's Department of Defence, provides the audience at the iTnews Data Centre Strategy Summit with a deep dive into the organisation's data centre consolidation program.
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
How Facebook designed the data centre from scratch - Marco Magarelli
The full keynote by Facebook data centre architect Marco Magarelli at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit. Magarelli details the design considerations behind the social network's Prineville, Oregon; North Carolina and Luleå, Sweden data centres.
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Modernising Legacy Data Centres - Telstra's Jon Curry
Telstra general manager of managed data centres Jon Curry guides the audience at the iTnews Australian Data Centre Summit through the build of the telco's Clayton, Victoria data centre.
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
NSW Government launches NABERS data centre rating tools
Matthew Clark from the NSW Department of Environment guides facilties managers through the details of the new NABERS data centre energy rating tool at the Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit.
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
NABERS launch panel: Australian Data Centre Strategy Summit
Matthew Clark (NSW Dept of Environment), Greg Boorer (Canberra Data Centres), Glenn Allan (National Australia Bank), Mike Andrea (Strategic Directions) and Bob Sharon (Green Global Consulting) discuss the impact of the NABERS data centre rating.
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Fortescue Metals [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Fortescue Metals 'New World of Work" project, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Retail [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss the shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Pacific Aluminium [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Pacific Aluminium's lightning fast service desk refresh, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Industrials category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Domino's Pizza [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Domino's Pizza's shift to hosted services, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: McDonald's Australia [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss McDonald's Australia's new self-service portal for employees, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Retail category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: ING Direct [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: ING Direct [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss ING Direct's 'Bank in a Box', one of three shortlisted finalists for the banking and finance category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Judges notes: Yarra Valley Water [The Benchmark Awards]
Judges notes: Yarra Valley Water [The Benchmark Awards]
iTnews' panel of judges discuss Yarra Valley Water's insourcing project, one of three shortlisted finalists for the Utilities category of the CIO Benchmark Awards.
Latest Comments
Polls
Do you prefer the Coalition's NBN policy?

   |   View results
Yes
  19%
 
No
  81%
TOTAL VOTES: 1641

Vote